Isles C G, Johnson A O, Milne F J
Br J Clin Pharmacol. 1986 Apr;21(4):377-83. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2125.1986.tb05210.x.
We have compared the efficacy and safety of slow release nifedipine and atenolol given orally as initial treatment for malignant hypertension. Twenty consecutive black patients with untreated malignant hypertension, whose diastolic pressure remained greater than 120 mm Hg after 3 h bed rest, were randomized to receive either slow release nifedipine 40 mg at 1 and 12 h, or atenolol 100 mg at 0 h only. Patients remained supine throughout the study. Blood pressure was measured using a semi-automatic recorder (Omega 1000) at 15 min intervals from -3 to 24 h. Baseline blood pressure was similar in the nifedipine (233/142 mm Hg) and atenolol (226/141 mm Hg) groups. The rate of fall of pressure was greater after nifedipine whose maximum hypotensive effect occurred 4-5 h after each dose. Blood pressure decreased more slowly and more enduringly after atenolol, although the extent of fall was the same (delta BP 5 h after first dose nifedipine = 67/41 mm Hg; delta BP 16 h after atenolol = 64/40 mm Hg). There were no precipitous falls in pressure. No patient developed focal neurological signs, nor was heart failure precipitated by either form of treatment. These results support recommendations that most patients with malignant hypertension can be managed without recourse to parenteral therapy.
我们比较了口服缓释硝苯地平和阿替洛尔作为恶性高血压初始治疗的疗效和安全性。连续20例未经治疗的恶性高血压黑人患者,卧床休息3小时后舒张压仍大于120mmHg,被随机分为两组,一组在1小时和12小时各服用40mg缓释硝苯地平,另一组仅在0小时服用100mg阿替洛尔。在整个研究过程中患者均保持仰卧位。使用半自动记录仪(Omega 1000)在-3至24小时内每隔15分钟测量一次血压。硝苯地平组(233/142mmHg)和阿替洛尔组(226/141mmHg)的基线血压相似。硝苯地平给药后血压下降速率更快,每次给药后4-5小时出现最大降压效果。阿替洛尔给药后血压下降更缓慢且更持久,尽管下降幅度相同(首次服用硝苯地平后5小时血压变化量=67/41mmHg;服用阿替洛尔后16小时血压变化量=64/40mmHg)。血压没有急剧下降。没有患者出现局灶性神经体征,两种治疗方式也均未引发心力衰竭。这些结果支持以下建议:大多数恶性高血压患者无需依靠胃肠外治疗即可得到控制。