Greminger P, Foerster E, Vetter H, Baumgart P, Vetter W
Klin Wochenschr. 1986 Apr 1;64(7):327-32. doi: 10.1007/BF01711952.
The antihypertensive efficacy of minoxidil and captopril was compared in 23 males with essential or renal parenchymatous hypertension refractory to conventional antihypertensive drug therapy. Following a pretreatment period the patients were randomly assigned to receive either minoxidil, 2.5 mg twice daily (n = 12), or captopril, 25 mg twice daily (n = 11). In patients with diastolic blood pressure greater than 95 mmHg, doses of minoxidil and captopril were increased in 2-week intervals. Patients who maintained diastolic pressure greater than 95 mmHg and/or those with intolerable side effects were switched over to the alternative substance. After a mean observation period of 12 weeks a significant decrease in systolic and diastolic blood pressure was observed (179/114 vs 148/92 mmHg in the minoxidil group; 176/111 vs 158/97 mmHg in the captopril group). The primary response rate was 75% in patients treated with minoxidil and 55% in those with captopril (not significant). After the change to the alternative substance two of the four non-responders on captopril and one of the two non-responders on minoxidil became responders. Side effects occurred significantly more often during minoxidil than captopril (p less than 0.05). The high efficacy of minoxidil and captopril in the treatment of severe hypertension refractory to conventional drugs was confirmed. Minoxidil lowered blood pressure slightly more than captopril, but it had a higher incidence of side effects than captopril.
对23名患有原发性或肾实质性高血压且对传统抗高血压药物治疗无效的男性患者,比较了米诺地尔和卡托普利的降压疗效。经过预处理期后,患者被随机分配接受米诺地尔,每日两次,每次2.5毫克(n = 12),或卡托普利,每日两次,每次25毫克(n = 11)。舒张压大于95 mmHg的患者,米诺地尔和卡托普利的剂量每2周增加一次。舒张压维持大于95 mmHg的患者和/或出现无法耐受副作用的患者改用另一种药物。经过平均12周的观察期,收缩压和舒张压均显著下降(米诺地尔组为179/114 mmHg对148/92 mmHg;卡托普利组为176/111 mmHg对158/97 mmHg)。米诺地尔治疗患者的主要缓解率为75%,卡托普利治疗患者为55%(无显著性差异)。改用另一种药物后,卡托普利治疗的4名无反应者中有2名以及米诺地尔治疗的2名无反应者中有1名变为有反应者。米诺地尔治疗期间副作用的发生频率显著高于卡托普利(p小于0.05)。证实了米诺地尔和卡托普利在治疗对传统药物难治的重度高血压方面具有高效性。米诺地尔降低血压的幅度略大于卡托普利,但副作用发生率高于卡托普利。