Buhl Mareike
Medizinische Physik, Carl von Ossietzky Universität Oldenburg, 26111 Oldenburg, Germany.
Cluster of Excellence Hearing4all, 26111 Oldenburg, Germany.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2022 Feb 11;12(2):463. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics12020463.
Common Audiological Functional Parameters (CAFPAs) were previously introduced as abstract, measurement-independent representation of audiological knowledge, and expert-estimated CAFPAs were shown to be applicable as an interpretable intermediate layer in a clinical decision support system (CDSS). Prediction models for CAFPAs were built based on expert knowledge and one audiological database to allow for data-driven estimation of CAFPAs for new, individual patients for whom no expert-estimated CAFPAs are available. Based on the combination of these components, the current study explores the feasibility of constructing a CDSS which is as interpretable as expert knowledge-based classification and as data-driven as machine learning-based classification. To test this hypothesis, the current study investigated the equivalence in performance of predicted CAFPAs compared to expert-estimated CAFPAs in an audiological classification task, analyzed the importance of different CAFPAs for high and comparable performance, and derived explanations for differences in classified categories. Results show that the combination of predicted CAFPAs and statistical classification enables to build an interpretable but data-driven CDSS. The classification provides good accuracy, with most categories being correctly classified, while some confusions can be explained by the properties of the employed database. This could be improved by including additional databases in the CDSS, which is possible within the presented framework.
常见听力学功能参数(CAFPAs)先前被引入作为听力学知识的抽象、与测量无关的表示形式,并且专家估计的CAFPAs被证明可作为临床决策支持系统(CDSS)中可解释的中间层。基于专家知识和一个听力学数据库构建了CAFPAs的预测模型,以便对没有专家估计的CAFPAs的新个体患者进行数据驱动的CAFPAs估计。基于这些组件的组合,本研究探讨了构建一个CDSS的可行性,该CDSS既要像基于专家知识的分类那样可解释,又要像基于机器学习的分类那样数据驱动。为了验证这一假设,本研究在听力学分类任务中研究了预测的CAFPAs与专家估计的CAFPAs在性能上的等效性,分析了不同CAFPAs对高且可比性能的重要性,并对分类类别差异进行了解释。结果表明,预测的CAFPAs与统计分类的结合能够构建一个可解释但数据驱动的CDSS。该分类具有良好的准确性,大多数类别被正确分类,而一些混淆可以通过所使用数据库的属性来解释。通过在CDSS中纳入额外的数据库可以改善这一点,这在提出的框架内是可行的。