Time-Dependent Efficacy of Checkpoint Inhibitor Nivolumab: Results from a Pilot Study in Patients with Metastatic Non-Small-Cell Lung Cancer.

HYPOTHESIS

Prior experimental and human studies have demonstrated the circadian organization of immune cells' proliferation, trafficking, and antigen recognition and destruction. Nivolumab targets T(CD8) cells, the functions, and trafficking of which are regulated by circadian clocks, hence suggesting possible daily changes in nivolumab's efficacy. Worse progression-free survival (PFS), and overall survival (OS) were reported for malignant melanoma patients receiving more than 20% of their immune checkpoint inhibitor infusions after 16:30 as compared to earlier in the day.

METHODS

Consecutive metastatic non-small-cell cancer (NSCLC) patients received nivolumab (240 mg iv q 2 weeks) at a daily time that was 'randomly' allocated for each course on a logistical basis by the day-hospital coordinators. The median time of all nivolumab administrations was computed for each patient. The study population was split into two timing groups based upon the median value of the median treatment times of all patients. CTCAE-toxicity rates, iRECIST-tumor responses, PFS and OS were computed according to nivolumab timing. PFS and OS curves were compared and hazard ratios (HR) were computed for all major categories of characteristics. Multivariable and sensitivity analyses were also performed.

RESULTS

The study accrued 95 stage-IV NSCLC patients (PS 0-1, 96%), aged 41-83 years. The majority of nivolumab administrations occurred between 9:27 and 12:54 for 48 patients ('morning' group) and between 12:55 and 17:14 for the other 47 ('afternoon' group). Median PFS (95% CL) was 11.3 months (5.5-17.1) for the 'morning' group and 3.1 months (1.5-4.6) for the 'afternoon' one ( < 0.001). Median OS was 34.2 months (15.1-53.3) and 9.6 months (4.9-14.4) for the 'morning' group and the 'afternoon' one, respectively ( < 0.001). Multivariable analyses identified 'morning' timing as a significant predictor of longer PFS and OS, with respective HR values of 0.26 (0.11-0.58) and 0.17 (0.08-0.37). The timing effect was consistent across all patient subgroups tested.

CONCLUSIONS

Nivolumab was nearly four times as effective following 'morning' as compared to 'afternoon' dosing in this cohort of NSCLC patients. Prospective timing-studies are needed to minimize the risk of resistance and to maximize the benefits from immune checkpoint inhibitors.