Razman Khalisah Khairina, Hanafiah Marlia M, Mohammad Abdul Wahab, Lun Ang Wei
Department of Earth Sciences and Environment, Faculty of Science and Technology, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, UKM, Bangi 43600, Selangor, Malaysia.
Centre for Tropical Climate Change System, Institute of Climate Change, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, UKM, Bangi 43600, Selangor, Malaysia.
Membranes (Basel). 2022 Feb 21;12(2):246. doi: 10.3390/membranes12020246.
A life cycle assessment of anaerobic-treated palm oil mill effluent (POME) was conducted to assess the environmental performance on two integrated treatment processes: the typical hollow fiber membrane ultrafiltration module coupled with adsorption and electro-oxidation as pretreatment. The analysis was undertaken using the ReCiPe 2016 method and SimaPro v9 software was employed using a 'cradle-to-gate' approach. The results showed that hollow fiber membrane from the adsorption integrated membrane impacted significantly at 42% to 99% across all impact categories for both processes. Overall, the electro-oxidation integrated membrane was discovered to have a lesser environmental impact, particularly on the ozone formation (human health) (HOFP) at 0.38 kg NOx-eq in comparison to the adsorption integrated membrane at 0.66 kg NOx-eq. The total characterization factor of the endpoint category for human health is 8.61 × 10 DALY (adsorption integrated membrane) and 8.45 × 10 DALY (electro-oxidation integrated membrane). As membrane treatment is closely linked to energy consumption, the environmental impact with different sources of energy was evaluated for both processes with the impacts decreasing in the following order: Grid > Biogas > Grid/Solar. Future research should concentrate on determining the overall 'cradle-to-grave' environmental impact of treating POME, as well as other scenarios involving membrane treatment energy utilization using LCA. This study can help decision-makers in identifying an environmentally sustainable POME treatment and management, especially in Malaysia.
对厌氧处理后的棕榈油厂废水(POME)进行了生命周期评估,以评估两种集成处理工艺的环境绩效:典型的中空纤维膜超滤模块与吸附和电氧化相结合作为预处理。分析采用ReCiPe 2016方法,并使用SimaPro v9软件采用“从摇篮到大门”的方法。结果表明,吸附集成膜中的中空纤维膜在两个工艺的所有影响类别中均产生了42%至99%的显著影响。总体而言,发现电氧化集成膜对环境的影响较小,特别是在臭氧形成(人类健康)(HOFP)方面,为0.38千克氮氧化物当量,而吸附集成膜为0.66千克氮氧化物当量。人类健康终点类别的总特征因子为8.61×10伤残调整生命年(吸附集成膜)和8.45×10伤残调整生命年(电氧化集成膜)。由于膜处理与能源消耗密切相关,因此对两个工艺评估了不同能源来源的环境影响,影响程度按以下顺序递减:电网>沼气>电网/太阳能。未来的研究应集中于确定处理POME的整体“从摇篮到坟墓”的环境影响,以及其他涉及使用生命周期评估进行膜处理能源利用的情景。本研究可帮助决策者确定环境可持续的POME处理和管理方法,特别是在马来西亚。