Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Laboratory of Epidemiology and Public Health, Yale School of Public Health, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
International Peace Maternity and Child Health Hospital, Shanghai Jiaotong University School of Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Matern Child Nutr. 2022 Apr;18(2):e13332. doi: 10.1111/mcn.13332. Epub 2022 Feb 25.
China has the largest and fastest-growing breast milk substitutes (BMSs) market and a disproportionately low exclusive breastfeeding rate. Many BMS manufacturers have established Chinese e-commerce stores. This marketing is of concern as it is likely to undermine breastfeeding. This study aimed to identify: (1) the marketing themes and strategies used to promote BMSs on the Chinese BMSs e-commerce websites; (2) if and how digital BMSs marketing may deviate from the World Health Organization Code of Marketing of Breast Milk Substitutes (the Code) recommendations. Content analysis was conducted on the flagship websites of 10 BMSs companies on the Chinese e-commerce platform "TMall" in July 2019. The main landing page (n = 10) of the flagship TMall website and the product description page (n = 113) of all individual formulas (Stages 1-3) within each company's TMall website were examined. The content was analysed and coded using an iterative thematic analysis approach. Emphasis on Premiumization and Science & Nutrition was the most commonly used marketing approaches. A total of 27.4% of the product description pages sampled used images of infants (<12 months), 33.6% made favourable comparisons of BMSs to breast milk, and only 34.5% included probreastfeeding statements. Marketing strategies were often inconsistent with the Code, and companies used "creative" ways to target mothers, often circumventing the Code recommendations. Unsubstantiated information was commonplace and of concern, because the e-commerce platform provided easy opportunities for bulk purchases. National regulatory actions are urgently needed to monitor online BMS marketing and the undermining of breastfeeding in China.
中国拥有最大且增长最快的母乳代用品(BMS)市场,但纯母乳喂养率却低得不成比例。许多 BMS 制造商在中国开设了电子商务商店。这种营销方式令人担忧,因为它可能会破坏母乳喂养。本研究旨在确定:(1)在中国 BMS 电子商务网站上推广 BMS 使用的营销主题和策略;(2)数字 BMS 营销是否以及如何偏离世界卫生组织《国际母乳代用品销售守则》(《守则》)的建议。2019 年 7 月,我们对中国电子商务平台“天猫”上 10 家 BMS 公司的旗舰网站进行了内容分析。对旗舰天猫网站的主要登陆页面(n=10)和每个公司天猫网站内所有配方(1-3 阶段)的产品描述页面(n=113)进行了检查。使用迭代主题分析方法对内容进行分析和编码。强调优质化和科学与营养是最常用的营销方法。抽样的产品描述页面中,有 27.4%使用了(<12 个月)婴儿的图片,33.6%将 BMS 与母乳进行了有利比较,只有 34.5%包含了支持母乳喂养的声明。营销战略往往不符合《守则》,而且公司采用了“创造性”的方式来针对母亲,常常规避了《守则》的建议。未经证实的信息很常见,令人担忧,因为电子商务平台为大量购买提供了便利。迫切需要国家监管行动来监测中国的在线 BMS 营销和对母乳喂养的破坏。