University of Missouri-Kansas City School of Medicine, 2411 Holmes Street, Kansas City, MO, 64108, USA.
University of Missouri-Kansas City School of Medicine, 2411 Holmes Street, Kansas City, MO, 64108, USA; Children's Mercy Hospital, 2401 Gillham Rd, Kansas City, MO 64108, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 2022 Jun;114(3):265-273. doi: 10.1016/j.jnma.2022.01.008. Epub 2022 Feb 25.
Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous groups have carried the burden of COVID-19 disease in comparison to non-marginalized groups within the United States. It is important to examine the factors that have led to the observed disparities in COVID-19 risk, morbidity, and mortality. We described primary health care access within large US metropolitan cities in relation to COVID-19 rate, race/ethnicity, and income level and hypothesized that observed racial/ethnic disparities in COVID-19 rates are associated with health care provider number.
We accessed public city health department records for reported COVID-19 cases within 10 major metropolitan cities in the United States and also obtained publicly available racial/ethnic demographic median income and primary health care provider counts within individual zip codes. We made comparisons of COVID-19 case numbers within zip codes based on racial/ethnic and income makeup in relation to primary health care counts.
Median COVID-19 rates differed by race/ethnicity and income. There was an inverse relationship between median income and COVID-19 rate within zip codes (rho: -0.515; p<0.001). However, this relationship was strongest within racially/ethnically non-marginalized zip codes relative to those composed mainly of racially/ethnically marginalized populations (rho: -0.427 vs. rho: -0.175 respectively). Health care provider number within zip codes was inversely associated with the COVID-19 rate. (rho: -0.157; p<0.001) However, when evaluated by stratified groups by race the association was only significant within racially/ethnically marginalized zip codes(rho: -0.229; p<0.001).
COVID-19 case rates were associated with racial/ethnic makeup and income status within zip codes across the United States and likewise, primary care provider access also differed by these factors. However, our study reveals that structural and systemic barriers and inequities have led to disproportionate access to health care along with other factors that require identification.
These results pose a concern in terms of pandemic progression into the next year and how these structural inequities have impacted and will impact vaccine distribution.
与美国的非边缘群体相比,黑人和西班牙裔以及原住民群体在 COVID-19 疾病方面承受了更大的负担。重要的是要研究导致 COVID-19 风险、发病率和死亡率出现观察到的差异的因素。我们描述了美国主要大都市城市的初级保健获取情况与 COVID-19 发病率、种族/族裔和收入水平的关系,并假设在 COVID-19 发病率方面观察到的种族/族裔差异与医疗服务提供者数量有关。
我们访问了美国 10 个主要大都市区的公共城市卫生部门记录的报告 COVID-19 病例,并获得了各个邮政编码内公开的种族/族裔人口中位数收入和初级保健提供者人数。我们根据邮政编码内的种族/族裔和收入构成,比较了邮政编码内的 COVID-19 病例数量与初级保健提供者人数的关系。
种族/族裔和收入状况不同,中位数 COVID-19 发病率也不同。邮政编码内的中位数收入与 COVID-19 发病率呈负相关(rho:-0.515;p<0.001)。然而,这种关系在种族/族裔非边缘化邮政编码内最强,而在主要由种族/族裔边缘化人群组成的邮政编码内则较弱(rho:-0.427 与 rho:-0.175 分别)。邮政编码内的医疗服务提供者数量与 COVID-19 发病率呈负相关。(rho:-0.157;p<0.001)但是,当按种族分层评估时,这种关联仅在种族/族裔边缘化的邮政编码内具有统计学意义(rho:-0.229;p<0.001)。
美国邮政编码内的 COVID-19 病例发生率与种族/族裔构成和收入状况有关,同样,初级保健提供者的获得情况也因这些因素而异。然而,我们的研究表明,结构性和系统性障碍和不平等导致医疗保健机会不均等,以及其他需要确定的因素。
这些结果令人担忧,因为疫情在未来一年的发展情况以及这些结构性不平等对疫苗分配的影响。