Department of Global Health, Boston University School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
Department of Epidemiology, Boston University School of Public Health, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS Med. 2023 Jan 31;20(1):e1004167. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1004167. eCollection 2023 Jan.
Inequities in Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) vaccine and booster coverage may contribute to future disparities in morbidity and mortality within and between Massachusetts (MA) communities.
We conducted a population-based cross-sectional study of primary series vaccination and booster coverage 18 months into the general population vaccine rollout. We obtained public-use data on residents vaccinated and boosted by ZIP code (and by age group: 5 to 19, 20 to 39, 40 to 64, 65+) from MA Department of Public Health, as of October 10, 2022. We constructed population denominators for postal ZIP codes by aggregating census tract population estimates from the 2015-2019 American Community Survey. We excluded nonresidential ZIP codes and the smallest ZIP codes containing 1% of the state's population. We mapped variation in ZIP code-level primary series vaccine and booster coverage and used regression models to evaluate the association of these measures with ZIP code-level socioeconomic and demographic characteristics. Because age is strongly associated with COVID-19 severity and vaccine access/uptake, we assessed whether observed socioeconomic and racial/ethnic inequities persisted after adjusting for age composition and plotted age-specific vaccine and booster coverage by deciles of ZIP code characteristics. We analyzed data on 418 ZIP codes. We observed wide geographic variation in primary series vaccination and booster rates, with marked inequities by ZIP code-level education, median household income, essential worker share, and racial/ethnic composition. In age-stratified analyses, primary series vaccine coverage was very high among the elderly. However, we found large inequities in vaccination rates among younger adults and children, and very large inequities in booster rates for all age groups. In multivariable regression models, each 10 percentage point increase in "percent college educated" was associated with a 5.1 (95% confidence interval (CI) 3.9 to 6.3, p < 0.001) percentage point increase in primary series vaccine coverage and a 5.4 (95% CI 4.5 to 6.4, p < 0.001) percentage point increase in booster coverage. Although ZIP codes with higher "percent Black/Latino/Indigenous" and higher "percent essential workers" had lower vaccine coverage (-0.8, 95% CI -1.3 to -0.3, p < 0.01; -5.5, 95% CI -7.3 to -3.8, p < 0.001), these associations became strongly positive after adjusting for age and education (1.9, 95% CI 1.0 to 2.8, p < 0.001; 4.8, 95% CI 2.6 to 7.1, p < 0.001), consistent with high demand for vaccines among Black/Latino/Indigenous and essential worker populations within age and education groups. Strong positive associations between "median household income" and vaccination were attenuated after adjusting for age. Limitations of the study include imprecision of the estimated population denominators, lack of individual-level sociodemographic data, and potential for residential ZIP code misreporting in vaccination data.
Eighteen months into MA's general population vaccine rollout, there remained large inequities in COVID-19 primary series vaccine and booster coverage across MA ZIP codes, particularly among younger age groups. Disparities in vaccination coverage by racial/ethnic composition were statistically explained by differences in age and education levels, which may mediate the effects of structural racism on vaccine uptake. Efforts to increase booster coverage are needed to limit future socioeconomic and racial/ethnic disparities in COVID-19 morbidity and mortality.
在马萨诸塞州(MA)社区内和社区之间,2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)疫苗和加强针接种覆盖方面的不平等可能导致未来发病率和死亡率的差异。
我们对一般人群疫苗接种推出 18 个月后的初级系列疫苗接种和加强针接种覆盖率进行了基于人群的横断面研究。截至 2022 年 10 月 10 日,我们从马萨诸塞州公共卫生部获取了按邮政编码(按年龄组:5 至 19 岁、20 至 39 岁、40 至 64 岁、65 岁以上)接种和加强针的居民的公共使用数据。我们通过将 2015-2019 年美国社区调查中的普查区人口估计值进行聚合,为邮政邮政编码构建了人口分母。我们排除了非居民邮政编码和包含该州 1%人口的最小邮政编码。我们绘制了邮政编码一级初级系列疫苗和加强针接种覆盖率的变化,并使用回归模型评估这些措施与邮政编码一级社会经济和人口统计学特征之间的关联。由于年龄与 COVID-19 严重程度和疫苗可及性/接种率密切相关,我们在调整年龄构成后评估了这些观察到的社会经济和种族/族裔不平等是否仍然存在,并按邮政编码特征的十分位数绘制了年龄特异性疫苗和加强针接种覆盖率图。我们分析了 418 个邮政编码的数据。我们观察到初级系列疫苗接种和加强针接种率的地理分布差异很大,按邮政编码一级的教育程度、家庭中位数收入、基本工人比例和种族/族裔构成存在显著不平等。在年龄分层分析中,老年人的初级系列疫苗接种率非常高。然而,我们发现年轻人和儿童的疫苗接种率存在很大差异,所有年龄组的加强针接种率也存在很大差异。在多变量回归模型中,“受过大学教育的百分比”每增加 10 个百分点,与初级系列疫苗接种覆盖率增加 5.1(95%置信区间[CI]为 3.9 至 6.3,p < 0.001)和加强针接种覆盖率增加 5.4(95%CI 为 4.5 至 6.4,p < 0.001)相关。尽管“黑人和/或拉丁裔/原住民百分比”和“基本工人百分比”较高的邮政编码的疫苗接种率较低(-0.8,95%CI -1.3 至 -0.3,p < 0.01;-5.5,95%CI -7.3 至 -3.8,p < 0.001),但在调整年龄和教育程度后,这些关联变得非常积极(1.9,95%CI 1.0 至 2.8,p < 0.001;4.8,95%CI 2.6 至 7.1,p < 0.001),这与年龄和教育群体内黑人和/或拉丁裔/原住民和基本工人群体对疫苗的高需求一致。“家庭中位数收入”与疫苗接种之间的强正相关在调整年龄后减弱。研究的局限性包括估计人口分母的不精确性、缺乏个人层面的社会人口统计学数据以及疫苗接种数据中潜在的邮政编码居住报告错误。
在马萨诸塞州一般人群疫苗接种推出 18 个月后,马萨诸塞州邮政编码的 COVID-19 初级系列疫苗和加强针接种覆盖率仍存在很大差异,特别是在年轻年龄组中。种族/族裔构成的疫苗接种覆盖率差异通过年龄和教育水平的差异得到统计学解释,这可能会影响结构种族主义对疫苗接种率的影响。需要提高加强针接种覆盖率,以限制未来 COVID-19 发病率和死亡率方面的社会经济和种族/族裔差异。