Princess Máxima Centre for Paediatric Oncology, Utrecht, the Netherlands.
Division of Oncology-Haematology, Department of Paediatrics, Kantonsspital Aarau, Switzerland; Division of Paediatric Haematology and Oncology, University Children's Hospital Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Eur J Cancer. 2022 Apr;165:146-153. doi: 10.1016/j.ejca.2022.01.034. Epub 2022 Feb 27.
There is an alarming delay in Europe for anticancer medicines becoming accessible for children. Following a paediatric European Union marketing authorisation, national Health Technology Assessment (HTA) agencies evaluate effectiveness, and safety of medicines to support decision on their cost and reimbursement. This study (a SIOPE Access to Medicines project) aimed to evaluate how these HTA evaluations take place for anticancer medicines indicated for paediatric use in Europe and to explore where the delays for market access originate.
We obtained HTA reports from the public domain for nine European countries for blinatumomab, dinutuximab beta and tisagenlecleucel. We evaluated the time elapsed between marketing authorisation for a paediatric indication and a national HTA decision and the nature of the decision.
Out of 23 HTA decisions (four countries without blinatumomab report), 18 were positive, two with restrictions, three negative. For blinatumomab, tisagenlecleucel and dinutuximab beta, the median time to an HTA decision after regulatory approval for paediatric use was 353 days (range 193-751), 141 days (range 77-517) and 515 days (range 0-780), respectively, with variability between countries. Dinutuximab beta and tisagenlecleucel were first introduced in children, but did not result in shorter time to HTA decision. For blinatumomab, marketing authorisation followed 1008 days after the indication in adults, with HTA applications submitted a median of 167 days later, and a recommendation after 145 days.
This study reveals ample variability in HTA decision making in nine European Union countries. Collaboration and alignment of required evidence is needed to facilitate robust scientific HTA assessments, also considering methodological challenges in paediatric oncology.
在欧洲,抗癌药物获得儿童使用许可的时间令人担忧。在欧盟儿科药品上市许可后,各国卫生技术评估(HTA)机构会评估药品的有效性和安全性,以支持其成本和报销的决策。本研究(SIOPE 药品可及性项目)旨在评估欧洲用于儿科的抗癌药物的 HTA 评估是如何进行的,并探讨市场准入延迟的原因。
我们从公共领域获得了欧洲九个国家的blinatumomab、dinutuximab beta 和 tisagenlecleucel 的 HTA 报告。我们评估了从儿科适应证获得药品上市许可到国家 HTA 决策之间的时间间隔以及决策的性质。
在 23 项 HTA 决策中(四个国家没有blinatumomab 报告),18 项为阳性,2 项有条件,3 项为阴性。blinatumomab、tisagenlecleucel 和 dinutuximab beta 从儿科使用监管批准到 HTA 决策的中位时间分别为 353 天(范围 193-751)、141 天(范围 77-517)和 515 天(范围 0-780),国家之间存在差异。dinutuximab beta 和 tisagenlecleucel 首先在儿童中使用,但并没有缩短 HTA 决策时间。blinatumomab 从成人适应证获得药品上市许可后 1008 天,中位 HTA 申请提交时间为 167 天后,建议时间为 145 天后。
本研究揭示了欧盟九个国家 HTA 决策存在广泛的差异。需要合作和协调所需的证据,以促进稳健的科学 HTA 评估,同时考虑到儿科肿瘤学中的方法学挑战。