Moot William, Crowe Marie, Inder Maree, Eggleston Kate, Frampton Christopher, Porter Richard J
Department of Psychological Medicine, University of Otago, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Front Psychiatry. 2022 Feb 14;13:767629. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.767629. eCollection 2022.
Studies typically report overall change in function when assessing bipolar disorder (BD) interventions, but individual domains are not analyzed. Which aspects of functioning are impacted is clearly important and may differ between treatments.
Data were analyzed from two previous clinical trials of Interpersonal and Social Rhythm Therapy (IPSRT) for BD patients. Change in total and subscale scores on the Social Adjustment Scale Self-Report (SAS-SR) from 0 to 78 weeks, were analyzed.
152 BD patients took part in randomized controlled trials of IPSRT ( = 38) vs. Specialist Supportive Care (SSC) ( = 43), and of IPSRT ( = 41) vs. treatment as usual (TAU) which was discharge to primary care ( = 30). IPSRT was superior to TAU on change in the social and leisure activities and extended family subscales, and SAS-SR total score over 18 months.
Studies were not designed to be pooled. Patients in study 1 were younger and symptomatic at baseline. Patients assigned to TAU were more likely to drop-out. Patients did not respond to subscales that were not personally applicable (work, marital, children).
IPSRT had a positive impact on two SAS-SR subscales compared to TAU over 18 months. Other subscales were limited by the lack of respondents due to individual applicability. Different psychotherapy may have differential effects on different domains of function. Measures of function and research into functioning in BD should include domain-based measures, and report the numbers of participants who respond to questions in each domain.
在评估双相情感障碍(BD)干预措施时,研究通常报告功能的总体变化,但未对各个领域进行分析。功能的哪些方面受到影响显然很重要,而且不同治疗方法之间可能存在差异。
对之前两项针对BD患者的人际和社会节律疗法(IPSRT)临床试验的数据进行了分析。分析了从0到78周社会适应量表自我报告(SAS-SR)总分及各子量表得分的变化。
152名BD患者参与了IPSRT(n = 38)与专科支持性护理(SSC)(n = 43)以及IPSRT(n = 41)与常规治疗(TAU,即出院后接受初级护理,n = 30)的随机对照试验。在社会和休闲活动、大家庭子量表的变化以及18个月的SAS-SR总分方面,IPSRT优于TAU。
研究并非设计用于汇总分析。研究1中的患者更年轻,基线时症状更明显。分配到TAU组的患者更有可能退出。患者对与个人无关的子量表(工作、婚姻、子女)没有反应。
与TAU相比,在18个月的时间里,IPSRT对两个SAS-SR子量表有积极影响。由于个体适用性问题,其他子量表因缺乏应答者而受到限制。不同的心理治疗方法可能对功能的不同领域有不同的影响。BD功能的测量和功能研究应包括基于领域的测量,并报告每个领域对问题作出反应的参与者数量。