IDMEC, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
Department of Mathematics and CEMAT, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal.
J Safety Res. 2022 Feb;80:254-269. doi: 10.1016/j.jsr.2021.12.007. Epub 2021 Dec 23.
Road traffic crashes represent a major public health concern, so it is of significant importance to understand the factors associated with the increase of injury severity of its interveners when involved in a road crash. Determining such factors is essential to help decision making in road safety management, improving road safety, and reducing the severity of future crashes.
This paper presents a recent literature review of the methods that have been applied to road crash injury severity modeling. It includes 56 studies from 2001 to 2021 that consider more than 20 different statistical or machine learning techniques.
Random Forest was the algorithm with the best results, achieving the best performance in 70% of the times that it was applied and in 29% of all studies. Support Vector Machine and Decision Tree achieved the best performance in 53% and 31% of the times and in 16% and 14% of all studies, respectively. Bayesian Networks and K-Nearest Neighbors achieved the best performance in 67% and 40% of the times that were used but only achieved the best performance in 4% and 7% of all the studies analyzed, respectively.
At this point, Random Forest revealed to be a good approach for road traffic crash injury severity prediction followed by Support Vector Machine, Decision Tree, and K-Nearest Neighbor. However, there is still a lot of room in this area to explore other techniques that can best suit this purpose as not only the model's performance should be considered but also causality issues, unobserved heterogeneity, and temporal instability. Practical Applications: This review enables researchers to understand the recent techniques applied in the analysis of injury severity modeling, and the ones that achieved the best performance results. Based on the reviewed studies, challenges and future research directions are presented.
道路交通碰撞是一个主要的公共卫生关注点,因此了解涉及道路交通碰撞的干预者受伤严重程度增加的相关因素具有重要意义。确定这些因素对于帮助道路安全管理中的决策制定、提高道路安全性和减少未来碰撞的严重程度至关重要。
本文对 2001 年至 2021 年期间应用于道路碰撞伤害严重程度建模的方法进行了文献综述。它包括 56 项研究,涉及 20 多种不同的统计或机器学习技术。
随机森林是表现最好的算法,在 70%的应用次数和 29%的所有研究中都取得了最佳性能。支持向量机和决策树在 53%和 31%的应用次数以及 16%和 14%的所有研究中取得了最佳性能。贝叶斯网络和 K-最近邻在 67%和 40%的使用次数中取得了最佳性能,但在 4%和 7%的所有分析研究中仅取得了最佳性能。
在这一点上,随机森林被证明是一种很好的方法,可以用于预测道路交通碰撞伤害严重程度,其次是支持向量机、决策树和 K-最近邻。然而,在这一领域仍有很大的空间可以探索其他技术,以最好地满足这一目的,因为不仅要考虑模型的性能,还要考虑因果关系问题、未观察到的异质性和时间不稳定性。
本综述使研究人员能够了解分析伤害严重程度建模中应用的最新技术,以及取得最佳性能结果的技术。根据综述研究,提出了挑战和未来研究方向。