School of Architecture and Design, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou, Jiangsu, China.
PLoS One. 2022 Mar 8;17(3):e0264482. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0264482. eCollection 2022.
Chinese commercial pedestrian streets have developed rapidly in recent years. However, people's preferences were not sufficiently considered and reflected in the outdoor space and landscape design. With the outdoor landscapes along commercial pedestrian streets in the region south of the Five Ridges as the research objects, this study revealed the public's different preference evaluations of the landscapes under the reciprocal effects of street characteristics. The main results were as follows: (a) When arcade spaces were available, people prefer streets with taller trees and a lower planting density (50 plants/km or less). Conversely, they preferred streets with relatively low trees (3-6 m), a higher planting density (100-200 plants/km) and two or more vertical layers of plants. People did not like the way that plants are lined in the middle of a street. (b) When there were only one or two types of signage hanging, people preferred streets with a moderate planting density (50-100 plants/km); and there were three or more types of signage hanging, people preferred the plants with low linear density (50 plants/km or less) and that were arranged along one or two sides of the street. (c) When benches were available, people preferred streets with plants on one or both sides, fewer plant colours (one or two kind of colours) and better plant growth status. Specifically, the richer the vertical structure and the bigger number of colours were, the higher the preference score. This study provided design schemes to enhance the visual quality of landscapes by improving landscape characteristics in similar outdoor spaces.
近年来,中国商业步行街发展迅速。然而,在户外空间和景观设计方面,人们的喜好并没有得到充分的考虑和体现。本研究以五岭以南地区商业步行街的户外景观为研究对象,揭示了街道特征相互作用下公众对景观的不同偏好评价。主要结果如下:(a)当有拱廊空间时,人们更喜欢树木较高、种植密度较低(每公里 50 株以下)的街道。相反,他们更喜欢树木相对较低(3-6 米)、种植密度较高(每公里 100-200 株)和具有两个或更多垂直层次的植物的街道。人们不喜欢植物沿街道中间排列的方式。(b)当只有一两种类型的招牌悬挂时,人们更喜欢种植密度适中(每公里 50-100 株)的街道;当有三种或更多类型的招牌悬挂时,人们更喜欢线性密度较低(每公里 50 株以下)且沿街道一侧或两侧布置的植物。(c)当有长凳时,人们更喜欢街道两旁有植物、植物颜色较少(一种或两种颜色)和更好的植物生长状态。具体来说,垂直结构越丰富,颜色种类越多,偏好得分越高。本研究通过改善类似户外空间的景观特征,为提高景观视觉质量提供了设计方案。