Department of Healthcare Leadership and Management, College of Health Professions, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA.
Department of Public Health Sciences, College of Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina, USA.
Telemed J E Health. 2022 Oct;28(10):1525-1533. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2021.0338. Epub 2022 Mar 8.
Cost studies of telehealth (TH) and virtual visits are few and report mixed results of the economic impact of virtual care and TH. Largely missing from the literature are studies that identify the cost of delivering TH versus in-person care. The objective was to demonstrate a modified time-driven activity-based costing (TDABC) approach to compare weighted labor cost of an in-person pediatric clinic sick visit before COVID-19 to the same virtual and in-person sick-visit during COVID-19. We examined visits before and during COVID-19 using: (1) recorded structured interviews with providers; (2) iterative workflow mapping; (3) electronic health records time stamps for validation; (4) standard cost weights for wages; and (5) clinic CPT billing code mix for complexity weighs. We examined the variability in estimated time using a decision tree model and Monte Carlo simulations. Workflow charts were created for the clinic before COVID-19 and during COVID-19. Using TDABC and simulations for varying time, the weighted cost of clinic labor for sick visit before COVID-19 was $54.47 versus $51.55 during COVID-19. The estimated mean labor cost for care during the pandemic has not changed from the pre-COVID period; however, this lack of a difference is largely because of the increased use of TH. : Our TDABC approach is feasible to use under virtual working conditions; requires minimal provider time for execution; and generates detailed cost estimates that have "face validity" with providers and are relevant for economic evaluation.
远程医疗 (TH) 和虚拟就诊的成本研究很少,报告的虚拟护理和 TH 的经济影响结果也不一致。文献中主要缺少确定 TH 与面对面护理成本的研究。本研究旨在展示一种经过修改的时间驱动作业成本法 (TDABC) 方法,以比较 COVID-19 前的面对面儿科诊所就诊和 COVID-19 期间相同的虚拟和面对面就诊的加权劳动力成本。我们使用以下方法检查了 COVID-19 前后的就诊情况:(1) 与提供者进行记录的结构化访谈;(2) 迭代工作流程映射;(3) 电子健康记录时间戳用于验证;(4) 工资的标准成本权重;和 (5) 诊所 CPT 计费代码组合的复杂性权重。我们使用决策树模型和蒙特卡罗模拟检查了估计时间的可变性。在 COVID-19 之前和期间为诊所创建了工作流程图。使用 TDABC 和不同时间的模拟,COVID-19 前门诊就诊的诊所劳动力加权成本为 54.47 美元,而 COVID-19 期间为 51.55 美元。大流行期间护理的估计平均劳动力成本与 COVID-19 前时期相比没有变化;然而,这种差异主要是由于远程医疗的使用增加。:我们的 TDABC 方法在虚拟工作条件下是可行的;执行所需的提供者时间最少;并生成与提供者具有“表面有效性”且与经济评估相关的详细成本估算。