Univ. Bordeaux, Inserm, Bordeaux Population Health Research Center, UMR1219, F-33000 Bordeaux, France.
Univ. Bordeaux, Inserm, Bordeaux Population Health Research Center, UMR1219, F-33000 Bordeaux, France.
Methods. 2022 Jul;203:142-151. doi: 10.1016/j.ymeth.2022.03.003. Epub 2022 Mar 10.
In health cohort studies, repeated measures of markers are often used to describe the natural history of a disease. Joint models allow to study their evolution by taking into account the possible informative dropout usually due to clinical events. However, joint modeling developments mostly focused on continuous Gaussian markers while, in an increasing number of studies, the actual quantity of interest is non-directly measurable; it constitutes a latent variable evaluated by a set of observed indicators from questionnaires or measurement scales. Classical examples include anxiety, fatigue, cognition. In this work, we explain how joint models can be extended to the framework of a latent quantity measured over time by indicators of different nature (e.g. continuous, binary, ordinal). The longitudinal submodel describes the evolution over time of the quantity of interest defined as a latent process in a structural mixed model, and links the latent process to each observation of the indicators through appropriate measurement models. Simultaneously, the risk of multi-cause event is modelled via a proportional cause-specific hazard model that includes a function of the mixed model elements as linear predictor to take into account the association between the latent process and the risk of event. Estimation, carried out in the maximum likelihood framework and implemented in the R-package JLPM, has been validated by simulations. The methodology is illustrated in the French cohort on Multiple-System Atrophy (MSA), a rare and fatal neurodegenerative disease, with the study of dysphagia progression over time stopped by the occurrence of death.
在健康队列研究中,通常会重复测量标志物来描述疾病的自然史。联合模型可以通过考虑因临床事件而导致的可能有信息缺失的情况,从而研究其演变。然而,联合建模的发展主要集中在连续的高斯标志物上,而在越来越多的研究中,实际的感兴趣的数量是不可直接测量的;它构成了一个潜在的变量,通过问卷或测量量表中的一组观察指标来评估。经典的例子包括焦虑、疲劳、认知。在这项工作中,我们解释了如何将联合模型扩展到通过不同性质的指标(例如连续、二项式、有序)来测量随时间变化的潜在数量的框架中。纵向子模型在结构混合模型中描述感兴趣的数量随时间的演变,该数量定义为一个潜在过程,并通过适当的测量模型将潜在过程与指标的每个观测值联系起来。同时,通过比例病因特异性风险模型对多因事件的风险进行建模,该模型将混合模型元素的函数作为线性预测因子,以考虑潜在过程与事件风险之间的关联。在最大似然框架下进行的估计,并在 R 包 JLPM 中实现,已经通过模拟进行了验证。该方法在法国多系统萎缩(MSA)队列中得到了说明,这是一种罕见且致命的神经退行性疾病,随着时间的推移吞咽困难的进展因死亡而停止。