University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Institute for Social and Health Sciences, University of South Africa, Lenasia, South Africa.
Health Promot Pract. 2022 Mar;23(2):325-330. doi: 10.1177/15248399211054779.
The higher education system globally is inherently inequitable. Discriminatory practices and oppressive power dynamics are particularly prevalent in the South African higher education landscape, which is characterized by a legacy of colonialism and apartheid. As a result, although students from a wide range of backgrounds are increasingly participating in higher education, many students who do not fit the dominant status quo question their belonging within these spaces. Students' experiences of alienation within higher education can have profoundly negative physical, pyschosocial, and education outcomes. However, students also display agency in negotiating the exclusionary institutional cultures within their universities and succeed despite these experiences. Photovoice methodology can be a useful tool for critiquing and highlighting such agentic practices, and for foregrounding the voices of students. In this research brief, we reflect on two photovoice projects that sought to examine the complexity of students' experiences of belonging and alienation in higher education in South Africa. Our findings illustrate that although students may experience alienation on campus, they may also create spaces of belonging, "speak back" to, and challenge the exclusions inherent to campus life.
全球高等教育系统本质上是不公平的。歧视性做法和压迫性权力动态在南非高等教育领域尤为普遍,该领域的特点是殖民主义和种族隔离的遗留问题。因此,尽管来自不同背景的学生越来越多地参与高等教育,但许多不符合主流现状的学生质疑自己在这些空间中的归属感。学生在高等教育中感到疏离会对他们的身心健康和教育成果产生深远的负面影响。然而,学生也在努力应对大学中排外的制度文化,并在这些经历中取得成功。摄影声音方法可以成为批判和突出这种代理实践的有用工具,并突出学生的声音。在这份研究简报中,我们反思了两个摄影声音项目,这些项目旨在研究南非学生在高等教育中归属感和疏离感的复杂性。我们的研究结果表明,尽管学生在校园中可能会感到疏离,但他们也可能创造归属感的空间,“回应”并挑战校园生活中固有的排斥现象。