Enyan Nancy Innocentia Ebu, Boso Christian Makafui, Ofori Anastasia Adomah, Agyare Dorcas Frempomaa, Aboh Irene Korkoi, Dike Nkechi Oluwakemi, Agyei Douglas Darko, Obiri-Yeboah Dorcas
Department of Adult Health, School of Nursing and Midwifery, University of Cape Coast, Cape Coast, Ghana.
Department of Medical Education and I.T, School of Medical Sciences, University of Cape Coast, Cape Coast, Ghana.
BMC Nurs. 2022 Mar 14;21(1):61. doi: 10.1186/s12912-022-00838-w.
Innovations in clinical nursing education are critical in enhancing the experiences of students, especially in the era of coronavirus pandemic. This study aimed at investigating nurse preceptors' perceptions of use, intention to use and self-efficacy towards digital technology in preceptorship in the Cape Coast Metropolis of Ghana.
A concurrent type of mixed-methods design with a non-randomised interventional study using three-phase multi-methods technique was conducted among nurse preceptors in the Cape Coast Metropolis in the Central Region of Ghana. Forty-five nurse preceptors participated in a pre and post training intervention while seven were purposively selected for the qualitative interview. Complimentarity method of triangulation was used in the analysis. The quantitative data were analysed with STATA version 16 and presented using frequencies, percentages, means with standard deviations and McNemar's test while qualitative data were analysed using the six steps approach to qualitative data analysis by Braun and Clarke.
Perceived usefulness statement "using technology will improve clinical teaching" increased from 19 (42.22%) at baseline to 44 (97.78%) post intervention. Perceived ease of using technology statement "I would find it easy to get this technology to do what I want it to do" also increased from 36 (80.00%) to 41 (91.11%) post intervention. Self-efficacy increased from 40 (88.89%) to 43 (95.56%) after the intervention. There was a statistically significant difference between pre-training and post-training scores regarding tablet (p = 0.016) and experience with online library resources (p = 0.039). The qualitative results yielded three themes, namely: strengths of using technology; constraints in the learning environment; and future of technological approach to clinical teaching.
The training intervention improved participants intentions, self-efficacy, perceived use and perceived ease of use of technology. However, there are constraints in the clinical learning environment including students and preceptor-related factors, and institutional factors that needs to be addressed as part of efforts to implement technology in clinical teaching in this era of COVID-19 pandemic and beyond.
临床护理教育的创新对于提升学生的体验至关重要,尤其是在新冠疫情时代。本研究旨在调查加纳海岸角大都会地区护士带教老师对数字技术在带教工作中的使用认知、使用意愿和自我效能感。
在加纳中部地区海岸角大都会的护士带教老师中开展了一项采用三相多方法技术的非随机干预性并行混合方法设计研究。45名护士带教老师参与了培训前后的干预,同时有7名被有目的地挑选出来进行定性访谈。分析采用了三角互证法。定量数据用STATA 16版进行分析,并以频率、百分比、均值及标准差和麦克尼马尔检验呈现,而定性数据则采用布劳恩和克拉克的定性数据分析六步法进行分析。
关于“使用技术将改善临床教学”这一感知有用性表述,从基线时的19人(42.22%)增至干预后的44人(97.78%)。关于“我会发现让这项技术按我期望的去做很容易”这一感知易用性表述,干预后也从36人(80.00%)增至41人(91.11%)。干预后自我效能感从40人(88.89%)增至43人(95.56%)。在平板电脑方面( p = 0.016)以及在线图书馆资源使用经验方面( p = 0.039),培训前和培训后的得分存在统计学显著差异。定性结果产生了三个主题,即:使用技术的优势;学习环境中的制约因素;以及临床教学技术方法的未来。
培训干预提高了参与者对技术的使用意愿、自我效能感、感知有用性和感知易用性。然而临床学习环境中存在一些制约因素,包括与学生和带教老师相关的因素以及机构因素,在新冠疫情时代及以后将技术应用于临床教学的努力中,这些因素需要得到解决。