Research, Evidence & Learning, VillageReach, Seattle, WA, USA.
Health Systems, VillageReach, Cape Town, South Africa
BMJ Open. 2022 Mar 15;12(3):e057245. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-057245.
Immunisations are highly impactful, cost-effective public health interventions. However, substantial gaps in complete vaccination coverage persist. We aimed to describe caregivers' immunisation experiences and identify determinants of vaccine dropout.
We used a community-based participatory research approach employing Photovoice, SMS (short messaging service) exchanges and in-depth interviews. A team-based approach was used for thematic analysis. The Increasing Vaccination Model guided the analysis and identification of vaccination facilitators and barriers.
This study was conducted in Zambézia province, Mozambique, in Namarroi and Gilé districts, where roughly 19% of children under 2 start but do not complete the recommended vaccination schedule.
Participants were identified through health facility vaccination records and included caregivers of children aged 25-34 months who were fully vaccinated (n=10) and partially vaccinated (n=22). We also collected data from 12 health workers responsible for delivering immunisations at the selected health facilities.
Four main patterns of barriers leading to dropout emerged: (1) social norms and limited family support place the immunisation burden on mothers; (2) perceived poor quality of health services reduces caregivers' trust in vaccination services; (3) concern about side effects causes vaccine hesitancy; and (4) caregivers hesitate to seek and advocate for vaccination due to power imbalances with health workers. COVID-19 created additional barriers related to social distancing, mask requirements, supply chain challenges and disrupted outreach services. For most caregivers, dropout becomes increasingly likely with compounding barriers. Caregivers of fully-vaccinated children noted facilitators, including accompaniment to health facilities or assistance caring for other children, which enabled them to complete vaccination.
Overcoming immunisation barriers requires strengthening health systems, including improving logistics to avert vaccine stockouts and building health worker capacity, including empathic communication with caregivers. Consistent and reliable immunisation outreach services could address access challenges and improve immunisation uptake, particularly in distant communities.
免疫接种是极具影响力且具有成本效益的公共卫生干预措施。然而,完全接种疫苗的覆盖率仍存在显著差距。本研究旨在描述照料者的免疫接种体验,并确定疫苗接种中断的决定因素。
我们采用基于社区的参与式研究方法,使用照片影像、短信息服务(SMS)交流和深入访谈。采用团队合作的方法进行主题分析。递增免疫模型指导了分析和识别疫苗接种的促进因素和障碍因素。
这项研究在莫桑比克赞比西亚省的纳马罗和吉尔区进行,那里大约有 19%的 2 岁以下儿童开始接种疫苗,但没有完成推荐的疫苗接种计划。
参与者是通过卫生机构的疫苗接种记录确定的,包括完全接种(n=10)和部分接种(n=22)的 25-34 月龄儿童的照料者。我们还从负责在选定的卫生机构提供免疫接种的 12 名卫生工作者那里收集了数据。
出现了四种主要的导致疫苗接种中断的障碍模式:(1)社会规范和有限的家庭支持使免疫接种负担落在母亲身上;(2)对服务质量的感知较差降低了照料者对疫苗接种服务的信任;(3)对副作用的担忧导致疫苗犹豫;(4)由于与卫生工作者之间的权力不平衡,照料者不愿寻求和倡导接种疫苗。COVID-19 带来了与社交距离、口罩要求、供应链挑战和中断的外展服务相关的额外障碍。对于大多数照料者来说,随着障碍的不断累积,疫苗接种中断的可能性越来越大。完全接种疫苗的儿童的照料者注意到一些促进因素,包括陪同去卫生机构或照顾其他孩子,这使他们能够完成疫苗接种。
克服免疫接种障碍需要加强卫生系统,包括改善后勤以避免疫苗缺货,并增强卫生工作者的能力,包括与照料者进行共情沟通。一致和可靠的免疫接种外展服务可以解决获得疫苗的挑战,提高疫苗接种率,特别是在偏远社区。