Jenkins Catherine L, Imran Sumayyah, Mahmood Aamina, Bradbury Katherine, Murray Elizabeth, Stevenson Fiona, Hamilton Fiona L
North East London Foundation Trust, Essex, United Kingdom.
eHealth Unit, Research Department of Primary Care & Population Health, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
JMIR Res Protoc. 2022 Mar 18;11(3):e32538. doi: 10.2196/32538.
Digital health interventions refer to interventions designed to support health-related knowledge transfer and are delivered via digital technologies, such as mobile apps. Digital health interventions are a double-edged sword: they have the potential to reduce health inequalities, for example, by making treatments available remotely to rural populations underserved by health care facilities or by helping to overcome language barriers via in-app translation services; however, if not designed and deployed with care, digital health interventions also have the potential to increase health inequalities and exacerbate the effects of the digital divide.
The aim of this study is to review ways to mitigate the digital divide through digital health intervention design, deployment, and engagement mechanisms sensitive to the needs of digitally excluded populations.
This protocol outlines the procedure for a systematic scoping review that follows the methodology recommended by the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews) guidance. The following databases will be searched for primary research studies published in English from October 1, 2011, to October 1, 2021: Cochrane Library, Epistemonikos, NICE Evidence, PROSPERO, PubMed (with MEDLINE and Europe PMC), and Trip. In addition, the following sources of gray literature will be searched: Conference Proceedings Citation Index, Health Management Information Consortium, International HTA Database, OpenGrey, The Grey Literature Report, Google Scholar Basic Search UK, MedNar Deep Web Search Engine, and Carrot2. We will select publications that meet the following inclusion criteria: primary research papers that evaluated digital health interventions that describe features of digital health intervention design and deployment that enable or hinder access to and engagement with digital health interventions by adults from demographic groups likely to be affected by the digital divide (eg, older age, minority ethnic groups, lower income, and lower education level). A random selection of 25 publications identified from the search will be double screened by four reviewers. If there is >75% agreement for included/excluded publications, the team will continue to screen all the identified publications. For all included publications, study characteristics will be extracted by one author and checked for agreement by a second author, with any disagreements resolved by consensus among the study team. Consultation digital health intervention design and deployment, and digital health intervention users will also be conducted in parallel.
The review is underway and is anticipated to be completed by September 2022.
The results will have implications for researchers and policy makers using digital health interventions for health improvement peripandemic and post pandemic, and will inform best practices in the design and delivery of digital health interventions.
INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): PRR1-10.2196/32538.
数字健康干预是指旨在支持与健康相关的知识传播,并通过数字技术(如移动应用程序)提供的干预措施。数字健康干预是一把双刃剑:它们有可能减少健康不平等,例如,通过为医疗设施服务不足的农村人口远程提供治疗,或通过应用内翻译服务帮助克服语言障碍;然而,如果设计和部署不当,数字健康干预也有可能加剧健康不平等,并加剧数字鸿沟的影响。
本研究旨在探讨通过设计、部署数字健康干预措施以及采用针对数字排斥人群需求的参与机制来缩小数字鸿沟的方法。
本方案概述了一项系统综述的程序,该综述遵循PRISMA-ScR(系统评价和Meta分析扩展的范围综述的首选报告项目)指南推荐的方法。将在以下数据库中检索2011年10月1日至2021年10月1日期间以英文发表的主要研究:Cochrane图书馆、Epistemonikos、NICE证据、PROSPERO、PubMed(包括MEDLINE和欧洲PMC)以及Trip。此外,还将检索以下灰色文献来源:会议论文引文索引、健康管理信息联盟、国际卫生技术评估数据库、OpenGrey、灰色文献报告、谷歌学术英国基本搜索、MedNar深层网络搜索引擎和Carrot2。我们将选择符合以下纳入标准的出版物:评估数字健康干预措施的主要研究论文,这些论文描述了数字健康干预设计和部署的特征,这些特征促进或阻碍了可能受数字鸿沟影响的成年人群体(如老年人、少数族裔、低收入和低教育水平人群)使用和参与数字健康干预。从搜索中确定的25篇出版物将由四名评审员进行双盲筛选。如果纳入/排除出版物的一致性>75%,研究团队将继续筛选所有确定的出版物。对于所有纳入的出版物,将由一名作者提取研究特征,并由另一名作者检查一致性,任何分歧将通过研究团队的共识解决。还将并行进行数字健康干预设计和部署以及数字健康干预用户的咨询。
综述正在进行中,预计将于2022年9月完成。
研究结果将对在疫情期间及疫情后使用数字健康干预措施改善健康状况的研究人员和政策制定者产生影响,并将为数字健康干预措施的设计和实施提供最佳实践参考。
国际注册报告识别号(IRRID):PRR1-10.2196/32538