Department of Clinical and Translational Science, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; Department of Surgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; Department of Surgery, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Department of General Medicine, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Transplant Cell Ther. 2022 Jun;28(6):340.e1-340.e16. doi: 10.1016/j.jtct.2022.03.013. Epub 2022 Mar 15.
Attrition of young adult registry members is a significant issue impacting hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) donation registries, including the Be The Match registry in the US. The resulting limited supply of allogeneic HSCs, used to treat serious health conditions, has a stronger impact on racial/ethnic minority groups in the US. Compared with young white adults, young adults identifying with these minority groups are more likely to drop out of the donor registry when called to donate. However, the underlying psychosocial factors that differ between white and nonwhite registrants have not been fully investigated. The central goal of this study was to examine demographic, registry-related, and donation-related characteristics in a young, newly registered group of potential donors and to determine whether these characteristics differed by, or were distributed differently among, racial/ethnic groups. We conducted a cross-sectional survey in a random sample of young (age 18 to 30 years) newly registered members, stratified by racial/ethnic group and sex. Demographic, registry-related (eg, context and motive for joining the registry), and donation-related (eg, ambivalence, religious objections to donation, knowledge about donation) characteristics were assessed. The chi-square test and analysis of variance were used to examine differences among racial/ethnic groups. Discriminant function analysis was used to assess whether patterns of the 3 classes of characteristics were associated with membership in particular racial/ethnic groups. A total of 524 participants were surveyed. Joining online was most common among white individuals, whereas joining at college was most common among black and Hispanic individuals. Ambivalence toward donation was higher among Asian/Pacific Islanders compared with white or multiracial/multiethnic individuals. Discriminant function analysis revealed 4 psychosocial/attitudinal functions predicting membership in certain racial/ethnic groups. The function accounting for the most variance in responses included mistrust of HSC allocation, religious objections to donation, low parental support, and low knowledge level. This function discriminated significantly between the white and nonwhite groups. Another function also identified ambivalence as a discriminating factor, which was most strongly associated with Asian/Pacific Islanders. Among young adult members of an HSC donor registry, such factors as ambivalence, family concerns about donation, mistrust of HSC allocation, religious objections, and less knowledge about donation were more strongly associated with membership in the nonwhite groups compared with the white group. These factors are known to be associated with a higher risk of opting out after having been preliminarily matched with a patient. The finding that these characteristics are associated with racial/ethnic minority group membership provides targets for recruitment strategies aimed at improving retention of young registry members.
成年造血干细胞捐献者的流失是影响造血干细胞(HSC)捐献登记处的一个重大问题,包括美国的 Be The Match 登记处。由此导致的供体 HSC 供应有限,用于治疗严重的健康状况,对美国的少数族裔群体影响更大。与年轻的白人成年人相比,当被要求捐献时,自认为属于这些少数族裔群体的年轻人更有可能退出捐献者登记处。然而,导致白人和非白人登记人之间存在差异的潜在社会心理因素尚未得到充分研究。本研究的核心目标是在一个年轻的新登记的潜在供体群体中检查人口统计学、登记处相关和捐献相关特征,并确定这些特征是否因种族/族裔群体而异,或者在这些群体中的分布是否不同。我们对年轻(18 至 30 岁)新登记成员进行了一项横断面调查,按种族/族裔群体和性别进行分层。评估了人口统计学、登记处相关(例如,加入登记处的背景和动机)和捐献相关(例如,矛盾心理、对捐献的宗教反对、捐献知识)特征。卡方检验和方差分析用于检查种族/族裔群体之间的差异。判别函数分析用于评估 3 类特征模式是否与特定种族/族裔群体的成员身份相关。共调查了 524 名参与者。白人最常见的加入方式是在线加入,而黑人和西班牙裔最常见的加入方式是在大学加入。与白种人或多种族/多种族裔个体相比,亚洲/太平洋岛民对捐献的矛盾心理更高。判别函数分析显示,4 种社会心理/态度功能可预测特定种族/族裔群体的成员身份。解释响应差异最大的功能包括对 HSC 分配的不信任、对捐献的宗教反对、低父母支持和低知识水平。该功能在白人和非白人之间有显著差异。另一个功能也将矛盾心理确定为一个区分因素,该因素与亚洲/太平洋岛民的关系最密切。在 HSC 捐献者登记处的成年成员中,与白人相比,犹豫不决、对捐献的家庭担忧、对 HSC 分配的不信任、宗教反对以及对捐献的了解较少等因素与非白人群体的成员身份更密切相关。已知这些因素与初步与患者匹配后选择退出的风险较高有关。这些特征与少数族裔群体成员身份相关的发现为旨在提高年轻登记成员保留率的招募策略提供了目标。