Picaud Myrtille
Pacte/CEE, Grenoble Alpes University, Grenoble, France.
Am J Cult Sociol. 2022;10(2):285-315. doi: 10.1057/s41290-022-00151-8. Epub 2022 Mar 12.
How do performances contribute to meaning-making processes in cultural fields? This paper focuses on the spaces where performances happen and how music is framed and staged by intermediaries. I engage critically with cultural pragmatics from a Bourdieusian perspective to argue that performance contexts are central to the structure of music scenes, and that fusion may be understood as a moment when the "rules of the game" (Bourdieu 1993) of a cultural field are enacted, perpetuated, or contested. This article points to the role that cultural intermediaries play in shaping performances, interpreting systems of collective representation, and achieving fusion. I devise a framework to analyze how the Parisian music scene is organized and structured by a pure/impure binary linking specific music genres to performance contexts. I also examine how cultural intermediaries in Paris work within this frame, playing with performance "rules" to shape audiences' understandings and experiences of music in particular venues. Drawing on ethnographic observations conducted in two major venues, I show how bookers attempt to transform the "rules of the game" and position their venues as part of the avant-garde by mixing "pure" and "impure" elements of performance during the events.
表演如何在文化领域的意义构建过程中发挥作用?本文聚焦于表演发生的空间,以及中介机构如何对音乐进行策划和呈现。我从布迪厄的视角批判性地探讨文化语用学,认为表演语境对于音乐场景的结构至关重要,融合可被理解为文化场域的“游戏规则”(布迪厄,1993)得以践行、延续或受到挑战的时刻。本文指出了文化中介在塑造表演、解读集体表征系统以及实现融合方面所发挥的作用。我设计了一个框架,用以分析巴黎音乐场景是如何通过将特定音乐流派与表演语境相联系的纯/不纯二元结构来组织和构建的。我还考察了巴黎的文化中介如何在这个框架内运作,通过在演出中运用表演“规则”来塑造观众在特定场所对音乐的理解和体验。基于在两个主要场所进行的民族志观察,我展示了演出预订者如何通过在活动期间混合表演的“纯”与“不纯”元素来试图改变“游戏规则”,并将他们的场所定位为先锋派的一部分。