Institute of Mechanics, Moscow University, Moscow, Russia.
Institute of Immunology and Physiology, Russian Academy of Sciences, Yekaterinburg, Russia.
Biophys J. 2022 Apr 19;121(8):1354-1366. doi: 10.1016/j.bpj.2022.03.023. Epub 2022 Mar 19.
Electron microscopy (EM) shows that myosin heads in thick filaments isolated from striated muscles interact with each other and with the myosin tail under relaxing conditions. This "interacting-heads motif" (IHM) is highly conserved across the animal kingdom and is thought to be the basis of the super-relaxed state. However, a recent X-ray modeling study concludes, contrary to expectation, that the IHM is not present in relaxed intact muscle. We propose that this conclusion results from modeling with a thick filament 3D reconstruction in which the myosin heads have radially collapsed onto the thick filament backbone, not from absence of the IHM. Such radial collapse, by about 3-4 nm, is well established in EM studies of negatively stained myosin filaments, on which the reconstruction was based. We have tested this idea by carrying out similar X-ray modeling and determining the effect of the radial position of the heads on the goodness of fit to the X-ray pattern. We find that, when the IHM is modeled into a thick filament at a radius 3-4 nm greater than that modeled in the recent study, there is good agreement with the X-ray pattern. When the original (collapsed) radial position is used, the fit is poor, in agreement with that study. We show that modeling of the low-angle region of the X-ray pattern is relatively insensitive to the conformation of the myosin heads but very sensitive to their radial distance from the filament axis. We conclude that the IHM is sufficient to explain the X-ray diffraction pattern of intact muscle when placed at the appropriate radius.
电子显微镜(EM)显示,从横纹肌中分离出的粗肌丝中的肌球蛋白头部在松弛状态下相互作用,并与肌球蛋白尾部相互作用。这种“相互作用的头部模式”(IHM)在动物界高度保守,被认为是超级松弛状态的基础。然而,最近的一项 X 射线建模研究得出的结论与预期相反,即在松弛的完整肌肉中不存在 IHM。我们提出,这一结论是由于使用了肌球蛋白头部径向坍塌到粗肌丝骨架上的厚丝 3D 重建模型得出的,而不是因为 IHM 的缺失。这种径向坍塌约为 3-4nm,在 EM 研究中对 negatively stained myosin filaments 的研究中得到了很好的证实,该重建就是基于此。我们通过进行类似的 X 射线建模并确定头部的径向位置对与 X 射线模式拟合度的影响来验证这个想法。我们发现,当将 IHM 建模到比最近研究中建模的半径大 3-4nm 的厚丝中时,与 X 射线模式的吻合度很好。当使用原始(坍塌)的径向位置时,拟合效果很差,这与该研究一致。我们表明,X 射线模式的低角度区域的建模相对不敏感于肌球蛋白头部的构象,但对它们距纤维轴的径向距离非常敏感。我们得出结论,当置于适当的半径时,IHM 足以解释完整肌肉的 X 射线衍射模式。