Huh Yoonjung, Lee Do-Hyeon, Choi Dalwoong, Lim Kyung-Min
College of Pharmacy, Ewha Womans University, Seoul 03760, Korea.
Transdisciplinary Major in Learning Health Systems, Department of Health and Safety Convergence Science, Korea University, Seoul 02481, Korea.
Toxics. 2022 Feb 24;10(3):108. doi: 10.3390/toxics10030108.
1,2-Benzisothiazolin-3-one (BIT) is a commonly used organic biocide containing an isothiazolone ring. However, it may have adverse effects on human health and its risk needs to be properly evaluated. Dermal exposure is the main route of BIT exposure, and co-exposed substances may affect its absorption. The dermal permeation profile of BIT has not been well-studied. This study aimed to investigate the dermal permeation profiles of BIT with or without cosmetic use. Dermal permeation profiles of BIT were investigated after infinite- (100 μg/cm), or a finite-dose (10 μg/cm) application with or without cosmetics using a minipig skin and Strat-M, an artificial membrane. A cream, lotion, and essence (namely, face serum) were pre-treated as representative cosmetics on minipig skin for 30 min, with BIT treatment afterward. After the treatment, BIT left on the skin surface was collected by cotton swabbing, BIT in the stratum corneum, by sequential tape stripping, and BIT retained in the remaining skin was extracted after cutting the skin into pieces before LC-MS/MS analysis. When an infinite dose was applied, permeation coefficients (K, cm/h) for minipig skin and Strat-M were 2.63 × 10 and 19.94 × 10, respectively, reflecting that skin permeation was seven to eight times higher in Strat-M than in the minipig skin. BIT, in the presence of cosmetics, rapidly permeated the skin, while the amount in the stratum corneum and skin deposit was reduced. We performed a risk assessment of dermally applied BIT in the absence or presence of cosmetics by calculating the skin absorption rate at 10 h based on the toxicological data from several references. The risk level was higher in the presence of essence as compared to lotion, which was higher than cream, which was higher than the control (non-treated). However, all of the margins of safety values obtained were greater than 100, suggesting that BIT is safe for use in dermally exposed consumer products. We believe that this research contributes to a greater understanding of the risk assessment of isothiazolinone biocides.
1,2-苯并异噻唑啉-3-酮(BIT)是一种常用的含有异噻唑啉酮环的有机杀菌剂。然而,它可能对人体健康产生不利影响,其风险需要得到妥善评估。皮肤接触是BIT接触的主要途径,同时接触的其他物质可能会影响其吸收。BIT的皮肤渗透情况尚未得到充分研究。本研究旨在调查有或没有化妆品使用情况下BIT的皮肤渗透情况。使用小型猪皮肤和人工膜Strat-M,在有或没有化妆品的情况下,分别以无限剂量(100μg/cm)或有限剂量(10μg/cm)涂抹BIT后,研究其皮肤渗透情况。将面霜、乳液和精华液(即面部精华)作为代表性化妆品在小型猪皮肤上预处理30分钟,之后进行BIT处理。处理后,用棉签收集残留在皮肤表面的BIT,通过连续胶带剥离收集角质层中的BIT,将皮肤切成小块后提取残留在剩余皮肤中的BIT,然后进行液相色谱-串联质谱(LC-MS/MS)分析。当应用无限剂量时,小型猪皮肤和Strat-M的渗透系数(K,cm/h)分别为2.63×10和19.94×10,这表明Strat-M中的皮肤渗透比小型猪皮肤高七到八倍。在有化妆品存在的情况下,BIT能迅速渗透皮肤,而角质层和皮肤沉积物中的含量则会减少。我们根据多篇参考文献的毒理学数据,通过计算10小时时的皮肤吸收率,对在有或没有化妆品情况下经皮肤涂抹BIT进行了风险评估。与乳液相比,有精华液存在时的风险水平更高,乳液的风险水平高于面霜,面霜高于对照(未处理)。然而,所有获得的安全边际值都大于100,这表明BIT用于皮肤接触的消费品是安全的。我们相信这项研究有助于更深入地理解异噻唑啉酮类杀菌剂的风险评估。