The First Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University, Shenyang, Liaoning Province, China.
BMC Geriatr. 2022 Mar 26;22(1):252. doi: 10.1186/s12877-022-02957-0.
Visual impairment (VI) seriously affects the quality of life of the older adults. It is important to formulate appropriate health management strategies for the older adults with VI to help delay the disease development and progression, and improve life quality. The aim of this study was to understand the demand preference for health management services of the older adults with VI, and to provide a reference for the development of future health management strategies in this population.
The conjoint analysis method was used to analyze demand preferences for health management services of the older adults with VI. 11 keywords were extracted after literature analyzed, 6 keywords were selected as the attributes of health management strategy after expert discussion and the level of each attribute was determined. Then 18 representative virtual health management strategies were formed by combination of different attribute levels through orthogonal design, and older adults with VI were asked to score. A total of 334 older adults with VI who attended the ophthalmology department of the First Affiliated Hospital of China Medical University and the Fourth People's Hospital of Shenyang from February 27, 2021 to June 30, 2021were enrolled in this study by stratified sampling. Of the 334 included people, 80 had grade 1 VI, 80 had grade 2 VI, 84 had grade 3 VI, and 90 had grade 4 VI.
The relative importance of health management services ranked by older adults with VI was continuing care (24.033%), visual aid application (19.61%), health education (16.241%), preventive healthcare (15.667%), safety management (12.757%), and rehabilitation training (11.392%). The utility values of each level of continuing care, safety management and preventive healthcare were positive, whereas the utility values of each level of visual aid application, health education and rehabilitation training were negative. The relative importance and utility values of health management services were different for the older adults with different grades of VI.
From the whole group, the older adults with VI have a higher preference for continuing care and a lower preference for rehabilitation training. The preference of the older adults with different grades of VI is different, so medical workers can formulate corresponding health management strategies according to their different demand preferences, and carry out hierarchical health management. Services that they preferred should be satisfied as much as possible in the health management strategy, while the reasons for the services with lower preference can be explored and make targeted improvement to meet the demand preferences of them.
视力障碍(VI)严重影响老年人的生活质量。为 VI 老年人制定适当的健康管理策略非常重要,有助于延缓疾病的发展和进展,提高生活质量。本研究旨在了解 VI 老年人对健康管理服务的需求偏好,为该人群未来健康管理策略的制定提供参考。
采用联合分析方法分析 VI 老年人健康管理服务需求偏好。文献分析后提取 11 个关键词,专家讨论后选择 6 个关键词作为健康管理策略属性,并确定各属性水平。然后通过正交设计组合不同属性水平形成 18 个具有代表性的虚拟健康管理策略,邀请 VI 老年人进行评分。本研究采用分层抽样,于 2021 年 2 月 27 日至 6 月 30 日,共纳入中国医科大学附属第一医院和沈阳市第四人民医院眼科就诊的 334 名 VI 老年人。纳入的 334 人,VI 程度 1 级 80 人,VI 程度 2 级 80 人,VI 程度 3 级 84 人,VI 程度 4 级 90 人。
VI 老年人对健康管理服务的相对重要性依次为延续护理(24.033%)、助视器应用(19.61%)、健康教育(16.241%)、预防保健(15.667%)、安全管理(12.757%)、康复训练(11.392%)。延续护理、安全管理和预防保健各水平的效用值为正,助视器应用、健康教育和康复训练各水平的效用值为负。不同 VI 程度老年人对健康管理服务的相对重要性和效用值不同。
从整体上看,VI 老年人对延续护理的偏好较高,对康复训练的偏好较低。不同 VI 程度老年人的偏好不同,医务人员可根据其不同的需求偏好制定相应的健康管理策略,进行分层健康管理。在健康管理策略中,应尽可能满足他们偏好的服务,同时探索服务偏好较低的原因,并进行针对性改进,以满足他们的需求偏好。