Imani Ali, Alibabayee Roghayeh, Golestani Mina, Dalal Koustuv
Tabriz Health Service Management Research Center, Health Economics Department, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Road Traffic Injury Research Center, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Front Public Health. 2022 Mar 14;10:830102. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.830102. eCollection 2022.
Measuring hospital efficiency is a systematic process to optimizing performance and resource allocation. The current review study has investigated the key input, process, and output indicators that are commonly used in measuring the technical efficiency of the hospital to promote the accuracy of the results.
To conduct this systematic review, the electronic resources and databases MEDLINE ( PubMed), Scopus, Ovid, Proquest, Google Scholar, and reference lists of the selected articles were used for searching articles between 2010 and 2019. After in-depth reviews based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria, among 1,537 studies, 144 articles were selected for the final assessment. Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) Checklist was used for evaluating the quality of the articles. The main findings of studies have been extracted using content analysis.
After the final analysis, the Context/Input indicators that were commonly considered by studies in analyzing hospital technical efficiency include different variables related to Hospital Capacity, Structure, Characteristics, Market concentration, and Costs. The Process/Throughput indicators include different variables related to Hospital Activity or services-oriented process Indicators, Hospital Quality-oriented process indicators, and Hospital Educational processes. Finally, the Output/Outcome indicators include different variables related to Hospital Activity-related output variables and Quality-related output/outcomes variables.
This study has identified that it is necessary to mix and assess a set of input, process, and output indicators of the hospital with both quantitative and qualitative indicators for measuring the technical efficiency of hospitals comprehensively.
衡量医院效率是优化绩效和资源配置的系统过程。当前的综述研究调查了常用于衡量医院技术效率的关键输入、过程和输出指标,以提高结果的准确性。
为进行这项系统综述,使用电子资源和数据库MEDLINE(PubMed)、Scopus、Ovid、Proquest、谷歌学术以及所选文章的参考文献列表,搜索2010年至2019年期间的文章。根据纳入和排除标准进行深入评审后,在1537项研究中,选择了144篇文章进行最终评估。使用批判性评估技能计划(CASP)清单评估文章质量。研究的主要结果通过内容分析提取。
最终分析后,研究在分析医院技术效率时通常考虑的背景/输入指标包括与医院容量、结构、特征、市场集中度和成本相关的不同变量。过程/吞吐量指标包括与医院活动或服务导向型过程指标、医院质量导向型过程指标以及医院教育过程相关的不同变量。最后,输出/结果指标包括与医院活动相关的输出变量和质量相关的输出/结果变量相关的不同变量。
本研究确定,有必要将医院的一组输入、过程和输出指标与定量和定性指标相结合并进行评估,以全面衡量医院的技术效率。