McBride Adam, Collins Claire, Osborne Brian, McVeigh Helen
ICGP, 4-5 Lincoln Place, Dublin 2, Ireland.
BMC Med Educ. 2022 Mar 31;22(1):220. doi: 10.1186/s12909-022-03292-z.
The Irish Medical Council has regulated mandatory continuing professional development (CPD) for doctors since 2011 to enhance the quality and safety of Irish healthcare. The Irish College of General Practitioners (ICGP), as the professional body for general practitioners (GPs) in Ireland, operates a Professional Competence Scheme (PCS) for doctors working in general practice. As PCS evolves over time, it is important to measure the impact of mandatory CPD on patient care. The ICGP undertook this study to answer the research question: Does CPD enhance patient care? Research has been conducted on the impact of CPD on the medical profession, both in Ireland and abroad, on GP engagement with existing CPD supports and on the impact of CPD for GPs in other countries. To date, no study has been carried out in Ireland on GP views on the impact of mandatory CPD on patient care or on which type of CPD activity is perceived to be the most effective in this regard.
All PCS enrollees on the 2018/2019 year who had provided an email address (n = 4,415) were asked to complete an anonymous online survey available in April and May 2019. The survey aimed to obtain feedback on existing CPD supports, enhancement of CPD supports, CPD impact on general practice and on patient care. The survey questions which related specifically to patient care were used to inform this paper.
A total of 1,233 (27.9%) PCS enrolees participated in the survey. Overall, 73.9% (n = 836) of respondents agreed that CPD assisted them in improving the quality of patient care with females significantly more likely to consider that CPD improved patient care. A total of 74.9% (n = 848) reported changes to patient management as a result of CPD activity and over half (56.4%; n = 464) of these believed that external CPD activity (courses/conferences) had the most potential to benefit their patient care, however, differences were observed across gender and age group.
The majority of GPs who completed the survey found CPD engagement beneficial to their patient care. The majority of respondents agree that peer engagement activities are most likely to impact patient care thus demonstrating that mandatory CPD has been successfully implemented in this respect in Irish general practice. However, there is a difference in response to the various CPD formats across different demographic cohorts and this should be considered when designing the format of educational activities.
自2011年以来,爱尔兰医学委员会一直在管理医生的强制性继续职业发展(CPD),以提高爱尔兰医疗保健的质量和安全性。爱尔兰全科医生学院(ICGP)作为爱尔兰全科医生(GP)的专业机构,为从事全科医疗工作的医生实施了一项专业能力计划(PCS)。随着PCS的不断发展,衡量强制性CPD对患者护理的影响非常重要。ICGP开展了这项研究,以回答研究问题:CPD是否能改善患者护理?爱尔兰国内外都开展了关于CPD对医学专业影响的研究,研究内容包括全科医生对现有CPD支持的参与情况以及CPD对其他国家全科医生的影响。迄今为止,爱尔兰尚未开展关于全科医生对强制性CPD对患者护理影响的看法,以及哪种类型的CPD活动在这方面被认为最有效的研究。
2018/2019年度所有提供了电子邮件地址的PCS注册人员(n = 4415)被要求在2019年4月和5月完成一项匿名在线调查。该调查旨在获取关于现有CPD支持、CPD支持的增强、CPD对全科医疗和患者护理影响的反馈。本文使用了与患者护理特别相关的调查问题。
共有1233名(27.9%)PCS注册人员参与了调查。总体而言,73.9%(n = 836)的受访者同意CPD帮助他们提高了患者护理质量,女性更有可能认为CPD改善了患者护理。共有74.9%(n = 848)的人报告由于CPD活动导致患者管理发生了变化,其中超过一半(56.4%;n = 464)的人认为外部CPD活动(课程/会议)最有可能使他们的患者护理受益,然而,不同性别和年龄组之间存在差异。
完成调查的大多数全科医生发现参与CPD对他们的患者护理有益。大多数受访者同意同行参与活动最有可能影响患者护理,这表明强制性CPD在爱尔兰全科医疗中在这方面已成功实施。然而,不同人口群体对各种CPD形式的反应存在差异,在设计教育活动形式时应考虑这一点。