1Department of Neurological Surgery, University of California, San Francisco.
2Weill Institute for Neurosciences, Brain and Spinal Injury Center, University of California, San Francisco.
Neurosurg Focus. 2022 Apr;52(4):E9. doi: 10.3171/2022.1.FOCUS21743.
Previous work has shown that maintaining mean arterial pressures (MAPs) between 76 and 104 mm Hg intraoperatively is associated with improved neurological function at discharge in patients with acute spinal cord injury (SCI). However, whether temporary fluctuations in MAPs outside of this range can be tolerated without impairment of recovery is unknown. This retrospective study builds on previous work by implementing machine learning to derive clinically actionable thresholds for intraoperative MAP management guided by neurological outcomes.
Seventy-four surgically treated patients were retrospectively analyzed as part of a longitudinal study assessing outcomes following SCI. Each patient underwent intraoperative hemodynamic monitoring with recordings at 5-minute intervals for a cumulative 28,594 minutes, resulting in 5718 unique data points for each parameter. The type of vasopressor used, dose, drug-related complications, average intraoperative MAP, and time spent in an extreme MAP range (< 76 mm Hg or > 104 mm Hg) were collected. Outcomes were evaluated by measuring the change in American Spinal Injury Association Impairment Scale (AIS) grade over the course of acute hospitalization. Features most predictive of an improvement in AIS grade were determined statistically by generating random forests with 10,000 iterations. Recursive partitioning was used to establish clinically intuitive thresholds for the top features.
At discharge, a significant improvement in AIS grade was noted by an average of 0.71 levels (p = 0.002). The hemodynamic parameters most important in predicting improvement were the amount of time intraoperative MAPs were in extreme ranges and the average intraoperative MAP. Patients with average intraoperative MAPs between 80 and 96 mm Hg throughout surgery had improved AIS grades at discharge. All patients with average intraoperative MAP > 96.3 mm Hg had no improvement. A threshold of 93 minutes spent in an extreme MAP range was identified after which the chance of neurological improvement significantly declined. Finally, the use of dopamine as compared to norepinephrine was associated with higher rates of significant cardiovascular complications (50% vs 25%, p < 0.001).
An average intraoperative MAP value between 80 and 96 mm Hg was associated with improved outcome, corroborating previous results and supporting the clinical verifiability of the model. Additionally, an accumulated time of 93 minutes or longer outside of the MAP range of 76-104 mm Hg is associated with worse neurological function at discharge among patients undergoing emergency surgical intervention for acute SCI.
先前的研究表明,术中维持平均动脉压(MAP)在 76 至 104mmHg 之间与急性脊髓损伤(SCI)患者出院时神经功能改善相关。然而,MAP 在此范围之外的暂时波动是否可以耐受而不会影响恢复尚不清楚。本回顾性研究在前一项工作的基础上,通过实施机器学习,为基于神经结局的术中 MAP 管理提供临床可操作的阈值。
74 例接受手术治疗的患者作为一项纵向研究的一部分进行回顾性分析,评估 SCI 后的结局。每位患者接受术中血流动力学监测,每 5 分钟记录一次,累计 28594 分钟,每个参数产生 5718 个独特数据点。收集使用的血管加压药类型、剂量、与药物相关的并发症、平均术中 MAP 以及处于极端 MAP 范围(<76mmHg 或>104mmHg)的时间。通过测量急性住院期间美国脊髓损伤协会损伤量表(AIS)等级的变化来评估结局。通过生成具有 10000 次迭代的随机森林,统计确定最能预测 AIS 等级改善的特征。递归分区用于为顶级特征建立临床直观的阈值。
出院时,AIS 等级平均提高了 0.71 级(p=0.002)。在预测改善方面最重要的血流动力学参数是术中 MAP 处于极端范围的时间量和平均术中 MAP。整个手术过程中平均 MAP 为 80-96mmHg 的患者出院时 AIS 等级改善。所有平均 MAP>96.3mmHg 的患者均无改善。确定了 93 分钟处于极端 MAP 范围的阈值,此后神经改善的机会显著下降。最后,与去甲肾上腺素相比,使用多巴胺与更高的严重心血管并发症发生率相关(50%比 25%,p<0.001)。
平均 MAP 值在 80-96mmHg 之间与结局改善相关,与先前的结果相符,并支持模型的临床验证。此外,在接受急性 SCI 紧急手术干预的患者中,MAP 范围为 76-104mmHg 之外的累积时间超过 93 分钟与出院时神经功能恶化相关。