Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Campus Charité Mitte, Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Berlin, Germany.
GMS J Med Educ. 2022 Feb 15;39(1):Doc3. doi: 10.3205/zma001524. eCollection 2022.
Handheld otoscopy is the standard tool used to teach ear examination in undergraduate and postgraduate medical education. Previous studies have shown that the undergraduate teaching of ear examination with handheld otoscopes is inadequate, resulting in low self-reported levels of student confidence in their diagnostic skills. With the increase in popularity of endoscopic ear surgery, an increasing number of otolaryngologists are using endoscopes for office examinations of the ear due to the method's superior visualization and excellent image qualities. However, medical students usually do not receive exposure to endoscopic ear examination during their undergraduate curriculum. The aim of this study is to assess our preliminary experience with teaching endoscopic ear examination to undergraduate medical students. A two-hour-long pilot practical course on basic ear examination was administered to undergraduate medical students with little to no previous experience with ear examination. The course was designed to minimize the duration of campus attendance and patient contact during the COVID-19 pandemic. The course included theoretical didactics, exemplary digital endoscopic images and peer physical practice of ear examination with both a handheld otoscope and a 0-degree endoscope. At the end of the course, the students completed a survey questionnaire consisting of eight questions mainly relating to their subjective confidence level with ear examination using either handheld otoscopes or endoscopes and their overall preference for either examination tool. Most students expressed a preference for ear examination with endoscopes over that with handheld otoscopes and reported an improved confidence level in their diagnostic ability with the former technique. The vast majority of students supported the teaching of endoscopic ear examination to future medical students. The findings of this pilot project report and survey study support the early exposure of novice medical learners to endoscopic ear examination, which may help improve the confidence and diagnostic skill of medical students with regard to ear examination. The findings may have implications for the undergraduate teaching of ear examination in the post-COVID-19 era.
手持式耳镜检查是本科和研究生医学教育中用于教授耳部检查的标准工具。先前的研究表明,使用手持式耳镜对本科生进行耳部检查的教学效果不佳,导致学生对自己诊断技能的自信程度自评较低。随着内镜耳部手术的普及,越来越多的耳鼻喉科医生由于该方法具有优越的可视化效果和出色的图像质量,在进行耳部门诊检查时使用内镜。然而,医学生通常在本科课程中没有接触到内镜耳部检查。本研究旨在评估我们在向本科医学生教授内镜耳部检查方面的初步经验。
我们向几乎没有耳部检查经验的本科医学生开设了一门两小时的基础耳部检查实践课程。该课程的设计目的是在 COVID-19 大流行期间最大限度地减少校园出勤率和患者接触。课程包括理论教学、示范数字内镜图像以及使用手持式耳镜和 0 度内镜对耳部进行同伴体格检查的实践。课程结束时,学生完成了一份包含八个问题的调查问卷,主要涉及他们使用手持式耳镜或内镜进行耳部检查的主观自信程度以及对这两种检查工具的总体偏好。
大多数学生表示更喜欢使用内镜进行耳部检查,而不是使用手持式耳镜,并报告说他们对前者的诊断能力更有信心。绝大多数学生支持向未来医学生教授内镜耳部检查。
该试点项目报告和调查研究的结果支持向新手医学学习者早期暴露于内镜耳部检查,这可能有助于提高医学生对耳部检查的信心和诊断技能。这些发现可能对 COVID-19 后时代的耳部检查本科教学产生影响。