The complex processes and interactions that regulate aging and determine lifespan are not fully defined for any organism. Here, taking advantage of recent technological advances in studying aging in budding yeast, we discovered a previously unappreciated relationship between the number of copies of the ribosomal RNA gene present in its chromosomal array and replicative lifespan (RLS). Specifically, the chromosomal ribosomal DNA (rDNA) copy number (rDNA CN) positively correlated with RLS and this interaction explained over 70% of variability in RLS among a series of wild-type strains. In strains with low rDNA CN, SIR2 expression was attenuated and extrachromosomal rDNA circle (ERC) accumulation was increased, leading to shorter lifespan. Suppressing ERC formation by deletion of FOB1 eliminated the relationship between rDNA CN and RLS. These data suggest that previously identified rDNA CN regulatory mechanisms limit lifespan. Importantly, the RLSs of reported lifespan-enhancing mutations were significantly impacted by rDNA CN, suggesting that changes in rDNA CN might explain the magnitude of some of those reported effects. We propose that because rDNA CN is modulated by environmental, genetic, and stochastic factors, considering rDNA CN is a prerequisite for accurate interpretation of lifespan data.