Meshki Razieh, Rashidi Marjan
School of Dental Medicine, Ahvaz Jundishapur University of Medical Sciences, Ahvaz, Iran.
BDJ Open. 2022 Apr 20;8(1):11. doi: 10.1038/s41405-022-00102-y.
This study aims to evaluate the discoloration rate of two types of composites, microhybrid and nanohybrid, after exposure to natural and commercially-produced juices.
In this experimental study, 90 disc-shaped specimens with a thickness of 2 mm and a diameter of 10 mm were taken from two composites, microhybrid P (Kerr-ITALY) and nanohybrid Filtek Z250XT (3M-ESPE-USA) (two groups of 45). Then, the samples of each group were divided into five subgroups of nine and were immersed for 10 days for 4 h in five solutions of commercially-produced orange juice, natural orange juice, commercially-produced pomegranate juice, natural pomegranate juice, and distilled water (control group). The colour of the samples was measured by a reflective spectrophotometer using the CLElab colour space at baseline and after discoloration.
The independent t-test showed that the mean discoloration rate (∆E) of nanohybrid composite exposed to commercially-produced orange juice, natural pomegranate juice, and commercially-produced pomegranate juice was significantly higher than microhybrid composite (P < 0.01). In addition, the test found that the highest discoloration rate of the nanohybrid composite was related to the effect of commercially-produced orange juice (∆E = 13.03) and the highest discoloration rate of microhybrid composite was related to the effect of natural pomegranate juice (∆E = 4.79).
According to the results, it seems that microhybrid composites are more resistant to discoloration than nanohybrid composites. According to the results, consumption of dyed drinks, particularly natural pomegranate juice, commercially-produced orange juice, and commercially-produced pomegranate juice, is not recommended in the first few days after composite restoration.
本研究旨在评估两种类型的复合材料,即微混合复合材料和纳米混合复合材料,在暴露于天然果汁和市售果汁后的变色率。
在本实验研究中,从两种复合材料,即微混合复合材料P(意大利克尔公司)和纳米混合复合材料Filtek Z250XT(美国3M-ESPE公司)中取出90个厚度为2毫米、直径为10毫米的圆盘形试样(两组,每组45个)。然后,将每组样品分成五个亚组,每组九个,并在市售橙汁、天然橙汁、市售石榴汁、天然石榴汁和蒸馏水(对照组)这五种溶液中浸泡10天,每天浸泡4小时。在基线和变色后,使用反射分光光度计在CIELab颜色空间中测量样品的颜色。
独立t检验显示,暴露于市售橙汁、天然石榴汁和市售石榴汁的纳米混合复合材料的平均变色率(∆E)显著高于微混合复合材料(P < 0.01)。此外,测试发现纳米混合复合材料的最高变色率与市售橙汁的影响有关(∆E = 13.03),微混合复合材料的最高变色率与天然石榴汁的影响有关(∆E = 4.79)。
根据结果,似乎微混合复合材料比纳米混合复合材料更耐变色。根据结果,在复合材料修复后的头几天,不建议饮用染色饮料,特别是天然石榴汁、市售橙汁和市售石榴汁。