Epidemiology, Centre for Radiation, Chemical and Environmental Hazards (CRCE), Public Health England, Chilton, Didcot, Oxon, United Kingdom.
Radiat Res. 2022 Jul 1;198(1):1-17. doi: 10.1667/RADE-20-00269.1.
Radiation worker studies provide direct estimates of cancer risk after protracted low-dose exposures to external X-ray and gamma-ray irradiations. The National Registry for Radiation Workers (NRRW) started in 1976 and has become the largest epidemiological program of research on nuclear workers in the UK. Here, we report on the relationship between solid cancer incidence and external radiation at the low-dose levels in 172,452 NRRW cohort members of whom (90%) were men. This study is based on 5.25 million person-years of follow-up from 1955 through the end of 2011. In the range of accumulated low doses two-thirds of workers have doses of less than 10 mSv. This study is an updated analysis of solid cancer incidence data with an additional 10 years of follow-up over the previous analysis of the NRRW cohort (NRRW-3). A total of 18,310 cases of solid cancers based on a 10-year lag were registered and of these 43% of the solid cancer cases occurred during the latest 10 years. Poisson regression was used to investigate the relationship between solid cancers risk and protracted chronic low-dose radiation exposure. This study demonstrated for solid cancers a rapid decrease of risk at high external doses that appeared to be driven by the workers who were monitored for potential exposure to internal emitters and who had also received relatively high external doses. Among cohort members only exposed to external radiation, a strong association was found between external dose and solid cancers (ERR/Sv = 0.52, 95% CI: 0.11; 0.96, based on 13,199 cases). A similar pattern is also seen for lung cancer. Excluding lung cancer from the grouping of all solid cancers resulted in evidence of a linear association with external radiation dose (ERR/Sv = 0.24, 95% CI: 0.01; 0.49, based on 15,035 cases), so suggesting some degree of confounding by smoking. Statistically significantly increasing trends with dose were seen for cancers of the colorectal, bladder and pleura cancer. Some of these results should be treated with caution because of the limited corroborating evidence from other published studies. Information on internal doses as well as non-radiation factors such smoking would be helpful to make more definitive inferences.
辐射工作人员的研究提供了在长期低剂量暴露于外部 X 射线和伽马射线辐射后癌症风险的直接估计。英国国家辐射工作人员登记处(NRRW)于 1976 年启动,已成为英国核工作人员最大的流行病学研究计划。在这里,我们报告了 172,452 名 NRRW 队列成员的固体癌发病率与外部辐射之间的关系,其中(90%)为男性。这项研究基于从 1955 年到 2011 年底的 525 万个人随访年。在累积低剂量范围内,三分之二的工人的剂量小于 10 mSv。这项研究是对 NRRW 队列(NRRW-3)之前分析的固体癌发病率数据的更新分析,在之前的分析中增加了 10 年的随访。共登记了 18,310 例基于 10 年潜伏期的固体癌病例,其中 43%的固体癌病例发生在最近的 10 年。使用泊松回归研究了固体癌风险与长期慢性低剂量辐射暴露之间的关系。这项研究表明,在高外部剂量下,癌症风险迅速下降,这似乎是由监测潜在内部辐射源暴露且也接受了相对较高外部剂量的工人驱动的。在仅暴露于外部辐射的队列成员中,发现外部剂量与固体癌之间存在很强的关联(ERR/Sv = 0.52,95%CI:0.11;0.96,基于 13,199 例)。对于肺癌,也存在类似的模式。将肺癌从所有固体癌的分组中排除后,发现与外部辐射剂量呈线性关联(ERR/Sv = 0.24,95%CI:0.01;0.49,基于 15,035 例),因此表明存在一定程度的由吸烟引起的混杂。随着剂量的增加,结直肠癌、膀胱癌和胸膜癌的癌症呈统计学上显著的上升趋势。由于其他已发表研究的证据有限,因此这些结果中的一些应谨慎对待。关于内部剂量以及吸烟等非辐射因素的信息将有助于做出更明确的推断。