School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia.
Institute for Climate, Energy, and Disaster Solutions, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT 0200, Australia.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Apr 12;19(8):4651. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19084651.
Classical agricultural development paradigms prioritise basic requirements such as agronomic, caloric and economic needs for the target environment and for beneficiaries. As challenges associated with climate change, globalisation, and population growth compound and amplify one another, project scope must be broadened to take a holistic food systems approach that includes sociocultural and historical contexts, as well as climate impacts as underpinning project design. In this paper, we illustrate the importance of adopting a food systems development paradigm rather than a classical agricultural development paradigm through a case study in Bougainville, Papua New Guinea. The case uses Rich Picturing, targeted and focus-group interviews, and garden visits in remote Bougainville; it provides a poignant illustration of the importance of this more holistic perspective given the historical inefficacy of food systems development, as well as Papua New Guinea's exposure to a plethora of compounding environmental, social, economic, and political stresses and shocks that demonstrate the important linkages between ecosystem services and health. The study aims to demonstrate how including localised gender dynamics, climate vulnerability, rapidly morphing social norms, and climate analogue environments is critical in building food systems resilience and is key to designing policies, programs, and development projects that more effectively address environmental, sociocultural, and health considerations. Building on the inadequacies in agricultural development efforts previously documented for Papua New Guinea, we propose an improved framing for food systems development and identify areas for future research.
传统的农业发展模式优先考虑目标环境和受益人的农业、热量和经济需求等基本要求。随着与气候变化、全球化和人口增长相关的挑战相互交织和加剧,项目范围必须扩大,采用整体的粮食系统方法,包括社会文化和历史背景,以及作为项目设计基础的气候影响。在本文中,我们通过巴布亚新几内亚布干维尔的一个案例研究来说明采用粮食系统发展模式而不是传统农业发展模式的重要性。该案例采用了丰富的描绘、有针对性的和焦点小组访谈以及对偏远布干维尔的花园访问;它生动地说明了这种更全面的视角的重要性,因为粮食系统发展在历史上是无效的,而且巴布亚新几内亚面临着大量复杂的环境、社会、经济和政治压力和冲击,这些压力和冲击表明生态系统服务与健康之间的重要联系。该研究旨在展示如何纳入本地化的性别动态、气候脆弱性、快速变化的社会规范和气候模拟环境,对于建设粮食系统的弹性至关重要,也是制定更有效地解决环境、社会文化和健康问题的政策、方案和发展项目的关键。基于之前为巴布亚新几内亚记录的农业发展工作的不足之处,我们提出了一个改进的粮食系统发展框架,并确定了未来研究的领域。