Merchie Emmelien, Heirweg Sofie, Van Keer Hilde
Department of Educational Studies, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
University of Applied Sciences, Bruges, Belgium.
Front Psychol. 2022 Apr 8;13:821768. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.821768. eCollection 2022.
In this study, 44 late elementary students' visual behavior patterns when reading mind maps were investigated, more particularly, the intuitive processing nature of their visual characteristics, reading sequence and presentation mode (i.e., mind map before or after text). Eye-tracked data were investigated by means of static early attention and dynamic educational process mining (EPM) analysis and combined with learning performance and retrospective interview data. All students seem to struggle with the map's radial structure during initial reading. Also, the picture's position in the map diverts students from consecutively reading interconnected branches. EPM analyses revealed different reading patterns in proceeding reading behavior. Students receiving a text first, seem to grasp the radial structure slightly more and show higher information integration attempts. They also attained higher free recall and coherence scores. The study concludes with instructional design principles for urgently needed explicit visual literacy instruction in elementary grades.
在本研究中,对44名小学高年级学生阅读思维导图时的视觉行为模式进行了调查,更具体地说,是对他们视觉特征、阅读顺序和呈现模式(即思维导图在文本之前还是之后)的直观处理性质进行了调查。通过静态早期注意力和动态教育过程挖掘(EPM)分析对眼动追踪数据进行了研究,并结合学习表现和回顾性访谈数据。所有学生在初次阅读时似乎都难以理解思维导图的放射状结构。此外,图片在思维导图中的位置会使学生无法连贯地阅读相互关联的分支。EPM分析揭示了后续阅读行为中的不同阅读模式。先接收文本的学生似乎对放射状结构的理解略多一些,并且表现出更高的信息整合尝试。他们在自由回忆和连贯性得分方面也更高。该研究最后得出了小学急需明确的视觉素养教学的教学设计原则。