Ho Brian S H, Chiu Peter K F, Lam Wayne, Wong Julius H F, Wong Charles K W, Lai Terence C T, Tsang Chiu-Fung, Ng Ada T L, Chan Chi-Kwok, Ma Wai-Kit, Ng Chi-Fai, Tsu James H L
Division of Urology Department of Surgery Queen Mary Hospital The University of Hong Kong Hong Kong Hong Kong.
Division of Urology Department of Surgery Prince of Wales Hospital Hong Kong Hong Kong.
BJUI Compass. 2020 Apr 22;1(2):74-81. doi: 10.1002/bco2.14. eCollection 2020 May.
Cancer is the second leading cause of death globally in 2018 with an estimated 9.6 million deaths. The costs of managing malignant ureteric obstruction (MUO) is a significant burden to any healthcare system. However, the management of MUO has long been a challenge for urologists. The standard options of percutaneous nephrostomy or polymer double J stents are fraught with problems. We report a large patient series with long-term follow-up in the use of Resonance metallic ureteric stents to relieve MUO, and identification of risk factors associated with stent failure.
All patients with MUO who were arranged to have Resonance metallic ureteric stent insertion at two university hospitals were included in this cohort study, starting from June 2011 to July 2016. Data were retrieved retrospectively. The primary outcome was the total duration of stent patency before stent failure due to malignant disease progression. Stent failure was defined as ureteric obstruction identified on imaging (functional radioisotope scan or antegrade pyelogram), acute renal failure resolved by subsequent percutaneous nephrostomy, or any other cause requiring stent removal prematurely. Secondary outcomes were identification of factors associated with stent failure, grade III or above complication, and development of a risk-adopted model to predict metallic ureteric stent patency rates in MUO patients. Median duration of functioning metallic ureteric stent was determined with Kaplan-Meier survival curve.
A total of 124 renal units in 95 patients with MUO were eligible for the study, with a median follow-up period of 22.9 months. About 106 (85.5%) renal units had successful metallic stent insertion, of whom 41 (33.1%) renal units ultimately progressed to ureteric obstruction despite the metallic stents, and required subsequent insertion of nephrostomies. Median duration of functioning metallic ureteric stents was 25 months. Female gender (HR 3.0, 95% CI: 1.3-7.2, = .014) and suspicious bladder lesion (HR 2.9, 95% CI: 1.4-6.2, = .005) were independent risk factors for stent failure, respectively. Stratifying patients into low (0 risk factor), intermediate (1 risk factor), and high (2 risk factors) risk groups, we found that this could predict the duration of stent patency in MUO with the metallic stents. (Low risk: 30.3 months vs intermediate group: 17.8 months vs high risk: 4.9 months, < .001).
Resonance metallic ureteral stents are able provide a median of 25 months of ureteric drainage in patients with MUO. Determining whether a patient has one or both risks factors (female gender and bladder lesion) will allow one to estimate the duration of metallic stent patency, which in turn may aid in determining cost-effectiveness in individual patients.
癌症是2018年全球第二大死因,估计有960万人死亡。管理恶性输尿管梗阻(MUO)的成本对任何医疗系统来说都是一项重大负担。然而,MUO的管理长期以来一直是泌尿外科医生面临的挑战。经皮肾造瘘术或聚合物双J支架等标准选择存在诸多问题。我们报告了一个大型患者系列,对使用共振金属输尿管支架缓解MUO进行了长期随访,并确定了与支架失败相关的风险因素。
本队列研究纳入了2011年6月至2016年7月期间在两家大学医院安排插入共振金属输尿管支架的所有MUO患者。数据进行回顾性检索。主要结局是由于恶性疾病进展导致支架失败前支架通畅的总持续时间。支架失败定义为影像学检查(功能性放射性同位素扫描或顺行肾盂造影)发现输尿管梗阻、随后经皮肾造瘘术缓解的急性肾衰竭,或任何其他需要提前取出支架的原因。次要结局是确定与支架失败、III级或以上并发症相关的因素,以及建立一个风险适应模型来预测MUO患者金属输尿管支架的通畅率。使用Kaplan-Meier生存曲线确定功能性金属输尿管支架的中位持续时间。
95例MUO患者的124个肾单位符合研究条件,中位随访期为22.9个月。约106个(85.5%)肾单位成功插入金属支架,其中41个(33.1%)肾单位尽管使用了金属支架最终仍进展为输尿管梗阻,并需要随后插入肾造瘘管。功能性金属输尿管支架的中位持续时间为25个月。女性(HR 3.0,95%CI:1.3 - 7.2,P = 0.014)和可疑膀胱病变(HR 2.9,95%CI:1.4 - 6.2,P = 0.005)分别是支架失败的独立风险因素。将患者分为低(0个风险因素)、中(1个风险因素)和高(2个风险因素)风险组,我们发现这可以预测MUO患者使用金属支架时支架通畅的持续时间。(低风险:30.3个月 vs 中风险组:17.8个月 vs 高风险:4.9个月,P < 0.001)。
共振金属输尿管支架能够为MUO患者提供中位25个月的输尿管引流。确定患者是否有一个或两个风险因素(女性和膀胱病变)将有助于估计金属支架的通畅持续时间,这反过来可能有助于确定个体患者的成本效益。