Al-Baghdadi Omaema, Barnick Christian, Srivastava Garima, Elbiss Hassan M
Omaema Al-Baghdadi, Tawam Hospital, Al Ain, UAE. Surrey University, Guildford, United Kingdom.
Christian Barnick, Homerton University Hospital, Homerton Row, London, United Kingdom.
Pak J Med Sci. 2022 Mar-Apr;38(3Part-I):583-588. doi: 10.12669/pjms.38.3.5215.
This study examined gynaecologists' experience and views on the management of vaginal vault prolapse (VVP) using laproscopic sarcocolpopexy (LSCP) versus open sarcocolpopexy (OSCP).
In a qualitative study conducted at the University of Surrey and Homerton University Hospital, UK, from 2016 to 2017, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 15 consultants experienced in minimal access surgery or urogynecology. Interviews were recorded and transcripts were analyzed using the qualitative description (QD) approach.
Eight broad themes emerged: VVP management, LSCP for management of VVP, OSCP and vaginal surgery with or without mesh use in VVP management, laparoscopic training and support as well as surgeons' attitude towards LSCP. All participants acknowledged the importance of LSCP in the management of post-hysterectomy VVP as benefits outweighed risks in their view. OSCP was considered suitable in very specific circumstances. Vaginal surgery could be an excellent alternative to OSCP bearing in mind long-term efficacy and sexual activity in young women. Most participants agreed with national recommendations to avoid use of mesh in vaginal surgery for VVP and expressed the view that it should be done in specialised centres by trained surgeons who do such operations.
This study showed that the acceptability of LSCP was dependent on participants' experience and consideration of the balance between patient's goals and potential risks. It provides useful guidance for future large-scale projects.
本研究探讨了妇科医生对采用腹腔镜骶骨阴道固定术(LSCP)与开放式骶骨阴道固定术(OSCP)治疗阴道穹窿脱垂(VVP)的经验和看法。
2016年至2017年在英国萨里大学和霍默顿大学医院进行的一项定性研究中,对15名在微创手术或妇科泌尿学方面经验丰富的顾问进行了半结构化访谈。访谈进行了录音,并使用定性描述(QD)方法对转录本进行了分析。
出现了八个广泛的主题:VVP管理、用于VVP管理的LSCP、OSCP以及VVP管理中使用或不使用网片的阴道手术、腹腔镜培训和支持以及外科医生对LSCP的态度。所有参与者都承认LSCP在子宫切除术后VVP管理中的重要性,因为在他们看来,其益处大于风险。OSCP被认为在非常特殊的情况下适用。考虑到年轻女性的长期疗效和性活动,阴道手术可能是OSCP的一个很好的替代方案。大多数参与者同意国家关于在VVP阴道手术中避免使用网片的建议,并表示应该由经过培训的专业外科医生在专门的中心进行此类手术。
本研究表明,LSCP的可接受性取决于参与者的经验以及对患者目标与潜在风险之间平衡的考虑。它为未来的大型项目提供了有用的指导。