Institute of Psychology, Jagiellonian University, Kraków, Poland.
PLoS One. 2022 Apr 28;17(4):e0267463. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0267463. eCollection 2022.
The continued influence effect of misinformation (CIE) is a phenomenon in which certain information, although retracted and corrected, still has an impact on event reporting, reasoning, inference, and decisions. The main goal of this paper is to investigate to what extent this effect can be reduced using the procedure of inoculation and how it can be moderated by the reliability of corrections' sources. The results show that the reliability of corrections' sources did not affect their processing when participants were not inoculated. However, inoculated participants relied on misinformation less when the correction came from a highly credible source. For this source condition, as a result of inoculation, a significant increase in belief in retraction, as well as a decrease in belief in misinformation was also found. Contrary to previous reports, belief in misinformation rather than belief in retraction predicted reliance on misinformation. These findings are of both great practical importance as certain boundary conditions for inoculation efficiency have been discovered to reduce the impact of the continued influence of misinformation, and theoretical, as they provide insight into the mechanisms behind CIE. The results were interpreted in terms of existing CIE theories as well as within the remembering framework, which describes the conversion from memory traces to behavioral manifestations of memory.
错误信息的持续影响效应(CIE)是指,某些信息尽管已经被撤回和纠正,但仍然会对事件报告、推理、推断和决策产生影响。本文的主要目的是研究使用接种程序可以在多大程度上减少这种效应,以及更正信息来源的可靠性如何对其进行调节。结果表明,当参与者未接种时,更正信息来源的可靠性并不影响其处理方式。然而,对于接种的参与者来说,如果更正信息来自高度可信的来源,他们对错误信息的依赖程度就会降低。对于这种来源条件,由于接种,对撤回的置信度显著增加,对错误信息的置信度也降低。与之前的报告相反,对错误信息的置信度而不是对撤回的置信度预测了对错误信息的依赖程度。这些发现具有重要的实践意义,因为已经发现了某些接种效率的边界条件,可以减少错误信息持续影响的影响,同时也具有理论意义,因为它们提供了对 CIE 背后机制的深入了解。结果根据现有的 CIE 理论以及记忆框架进行了解释,该框架描述了从记忆痕迹到记忆行为表现的转换。