David T J
Arch Dis Child. 1987 Feb;62(2):119-22. doi: 10.1136/adc.62.2.119.
Double blind challenges with tartrazine and benzoic acid were performed in hospital in 24 children whose parents gave a definite history of a purely behavioural immediate adverse reaction to one of these substances. The patients, whose ages ranged from 1.6 to 12.4 years, were on a diet that avoided these items, and in all there was a clear history that any lapse of the diet caused an obvious adverse behavioural reaction within two hours. In no patient was any change in behaviour noted either by the parents or the nursing staff after the administration of placebo or active substances. Twenty two patients returned to a normal diet without problems, but the parents of two children insisted on continuing the diet. While popular belief has it that additives may have harmful behavioural effects, objective verification is required to prevent overdiagnosis.
对24名儿童在医院进行了酒石黄和苯甲酸的双盲激发试验,这些儿童的父母明确表示孩子曾对其中一种物质出现过单纯行为性的即刻不良反应。患者年龄在1.6至12.4岁之间,当时遵循避免食用这些物质的饮食方案,而且所有患者都有明确的病史,即饮食中任何一次摄入这些物质都会在两小时内引发明显的行为不良反应。在给予安慰剂或活性物质后,家长和护理人员均未观察到任何一名患者的行为有变化。22名患者恢复正常饮食且无问题,但两名儿童的家长坚持继续该饮食方案。虽然普遍认为添加剂可能有有害的行为影响,但需要客观验证以防止过度诊断。