Pelly Diane, Daly Michael, Delaney Liam, Doyle Orla
Department of Economics, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Department of Psychology, Maynooth University, Maynooth, Ireland.
Front Psychol. 2022 Apr 5;13:823080. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.823080. eCollection 2022.
COVID-19 created a transformational shift in the working environment for much of the labour force, yet its impact on workers is unclear. This study uses longitudinal data to examine the wellbeing of 621 full-time workers assessed before (November 2019-February 2020) and during (May-June 2020) the first lockdown in the United Kingdom. We employ fixed effects analyses to investigate the impact of the restrictions and mandatory homeworking on cognitive, emotional, and psychological wellbeing. Within the sample, the rate of full-time homeworking increased from 2 to 74% between waves. We identify significant changes in 9 of the 15 measures assessed, with a general pattern of improvements in wellbeing during lockdown. Overall levels of stress, self-rated mental health, positive emotions and life and job satisfaction are not adversely affected by the restrictions. There is a reduction in the burnout symptoms of disengagement (-0.13 sd) and exhaustion (-0.20 sd) and in the frequency with which negative emotions are experienced at work (-0.15 sd). Workers feel more autonomous (+0.09 sd), closer to their co-workers (+0.10 sd), and more attached to their organisations (+0.19 sd). However, homelife satisfaction declines (-0.11 sd). These findings highlight the possibility that the COVID-19 pandemic and large-scale transition to homeworking was associated with unchanged or improved worker wellbeing. This study has important implications for governments and employers regarding a global shift to homeworking.
新冠疫情给大部分劳动力的工作环境带来了变革性转变,但其对劳动者的影响尚不明晰。本研究利用纵向数据,对621名全职工人在英国首次封锁前(2019年11月至2020年2月)和封锁期间(2020年5月至6月)的福祉状况进行了考察。我们采用固定效应分析方法,来探究限制措施和强制居家办公对认知、情绪及心理健康的影响。在样本中,两轮调查期间全职工人居家办公的比例从2%增至74%。我们发现,在所评估的15项指标中有9项出现了显著变化,总体呈现出封锁期间福祉状况有所改善的趋势。压力、自评心理健康、积极情绪以及生活和工作满意度的总体水平并未受到这些限制措施的不利影响。工作倦怠中的脱离感症状(-0.13标准差)、疲惫感症状(-0.20标准差)以及工作中负面情绪出现的频率(-0.15标准差)均有所降低。员工感觉自己更具自主性(+0.09标准差)、与同事关系更亲近(+0.10标准差)、对所在组织更有归属感(+0.19标准差)。然而,家庭生活满意度有所下降(-0.11标准差)。这些发现凸显了这样一种可能性,即新冠疫情以及向居家办公的大规模转变与劳动者福祉状况未变或改善有关。本研究对于政府和雇主在全球向居家办公转变方面具有重要意义。