Medical Student, 51374Western Michigan University Homer Stryker M.D. School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, MI, USA.
Surg Innov. 2023 Feb;30(1):84-93. doi: 10.1177/15533506221094956. Epub 2022 May 2.
While instructional videos are commonly used in surgical education, there is a paucity of data on home laparoscopic box trainers. This pilot study evaluated impacts of augmenting instructional videos with these devices. This was a randomized controlled pilot study evaluating laparoscopic surgical performance on the LapSim virtual surgical simulator before and after a 2 week curriculum of instructional videos alone (n = 8, 47.1%) vs videos plus a home laparoscopic box trainer (n = 9, 52.9%). The LapSim recorded mistake number, time, and instrument path length to complete each task. Participants completed surveys about their perceptions of surgery before and after the course. Preclinical medical students were recruited. Those with extensive surgical experience or did not complete the course were excluded. For the box trainer group vs the videos alone group: mean change in mistakes was -10.0 (standard deviation [SD]:17.1) vs +.5 (SD:21.59) ( = .28); mean change in time was -433.24 (SD:304.67) seconds vs -366.16 (SD:240.10) seconds ( = .62); mean change in instrument path length was -4.27 (SD:4.38) meters vs -3.19 (SD:4.86) meters ( = .64). The box trainer group ranked "I feel as though surgery comes naturally" 1.58 points higher (95% confidence interval [CI]: .85, 2.32; < .01) and "I am worried about being skilled at surgery" 1.26 points lower (95% CI: 2.29, -.24; = .02) upon completing the study. The videos alone group reported no significant changes in survey responses. Home laparoscopic box trainers can generate confidence and reduce anxiety regarding surgical fields. This study provides a framework for future larger scale works.
虽然教学视频在外科教学中被广泛使用,但关于家庭腹腔镜箱式训练器的数据却很少。本研究旨在评估这些设备与教学视频结合使用对腹腔镜手术技能的影响。这是一项随机对照的初步研究,评估了 17 名医学生在接受为期 2 周的教学视频课程(47.1%,n=8)或视频课程加家庭腹腔镜箱式训练器(52.9%,n=9)后,在 LapSim 虚拟手术模拟器上进行腹腔镜手术的表现。LapSim 记录了完成每个任务的错误数量、时间和器械路径长度。参与者在课程前后完成了关于他们对手术看法的调查。参与者为医预临床学生,排除了有丰富手术经验或未完成课程的学生。与仅观看视频组相比,使用腹腔镜箱式训练器组的错误数减少了 10.0(标准差[SD]:17.1),而增加了 0.5(SD:21.59)( =.28);时间减少了 433.24(SD:304.67)秒,而减少了 366.16(SD:240.10)秒( =.62);器械路径长度减少了 4.27(SD:4.38)米,而减少了 3.19(SD:4.86)米( =.64)。使用腹腔镜箱式训练器组的学生在完成课程后,对“我觉得手术很自然”的评分提高了 1.58 分(95%置信区间[CI]:0.85,2.32; <.01),对“我担心自己在手术方面很熟练”的评分降低了 1.26 分(95% CI:2.29,-0.24; =.02)。仅观看视频组在调查反馈中没有显著变化。家庭腹腔镜箱式训练器可以增强对手术领域的信心并减少焦虑。本研究为未来更大规模的研究提供了框架。