School of Psychology, Speech and Hearing, 2496University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
School of Psychology, 1415University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Sex Abuse. 2023 Mar;35(2):241-260. doi: 10.1177/10790632221098354. Epub 2022 May 4.
Sexual recidivism risk assessment tools focus almost exclusively on risk factors associated with increased rates of recidivism and do not attend to protective factors that might mitigate reoffense risk. The present study investigated the predictive validity of the Structured Assessment of Protective Factors - Sexual Offence version (SAPROF-SO), developed to assess hypothesised protective factors against sexual recidivism in adult males. The SAPROF-SO pilot version contains 24 items across two domains: Personal and Professionally Provided Support. SAPROF-SO scores were rated retrospectively from a review of archived case files of 210 men with convictions for child sexual offenses, using the SAPROF-SO pilot manual and a supplementary retrospective scoring guide developed for the current study. SAPROF-SO Total and Personal domain scores were significantly predictive of sexual recidivism after an average follow-up period of 12.24 years (AUC = .81), and to a lesser extent, violent and general recidivism. SAPROF-SO Total and Personal scores additionally provided significant incremental validity over Static-99R scores in the prediction of sexual recidivism. Results support the predictive validity of protective factors for reduced sexual recidivism and invite future research examining how to integrate the SAPROF-SO alongside contemporary sexual recidivism risk assessment tools.
性犯罪再犯风险评估工具几乎完全专注于与再犯率增加相关的风险因素,而不关注可能减轻再次犯罪风险的保护因素。本研究调查了旨在评估成年男性性犯罪再犯假设保护因素的《性犯罪版结构化保护因素评估》(SAPROF-SO)的预测有效性。SAPROF-SO 试点版本包含两个领域的 24 个项目:个人和专业提供的支持。使用 SAPROF-SO 试点手册和为当前研究开发的补充回顾性评分指南,从对 210 名因儿童性犯罪被定罪的男性的档案案例回顾中对 SAPROF-SO 评分进行了回顾性评分。SAPROF-SO 总分和个人领域得分在平均 12.24 年的随访后对性再犯具有显著的预测性(AUC=.81),对暴力和一般再犯的预测性稍差。SAPROF-SO 总分和个人得分在预测性再犯方面,相较于静态-99R 评分,提供了显著的增量有效性。研究结果支持保护因素在减少性再犯方面的预测有效性,并邀请未来的研究来检验如何将 SAPROF-SO 与当代性再犯风险评估工具结合起来。