Yates Kim M, Webster Craig S, Jowsey Tanisha, Weller Jennifer M
North Shore & Waitakere Emergency Departments, Waitemata District Health Board, Auckland, New Zealand.
Centre for Medical & Health Sciences Education, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
BMJ Simul Technol Enhanc Learn. 2015 May 18;1(1):33-39. doi: 10.1136/bmjstel-2014-000004. eCollection 2015.
Despite the use of in situ simulation in the emergency department (ED) for training staff to better manage critical events, little is known about how such training is experienced by patients in the ED during these simulations. We therefore aimed to explore ED patient knowledge and perceptions about staff training for emergencies, as well as their views about simulation generally, and in the ED setting specifically.
In this qualitative study, we used an interpretive approach involving video elicitation and semistructured interviews with patients who were waiting for treatment in the ED. Patients who agreed to participate were asked about their knowledge of simulation and were then shown a short video of a simulated resuscitation from cardiac arrest. We asked participants open-ended questions about their perspectives on the film and their views and about simulation training in the ED. Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed and analysed using thematic analysis.
We interviewed 15 participants. Most had little or no prior knowledge of simulation training. Watching the video elicited emotional responses in some participants, and pragmatic responses concerning staff training in others, with most participants viewing simulation training as useful and necessary. Participants said that to avoid unnecessary stress, they would prefer to be notified of when simulations were occurring, and what they could expect to see and hear during simulations. Most participants predicted that they would be willing to wait slightly longer (approximately 30 min) to see a doctor while simulation training was conducted, provided they did not require urgent medical attention.
Patient-centred care and care partnerships between patients and healthcare professionals underpin New Zealand healthcare and medical education ideologies. This requires effective communication between all parties, as evident in our study of in situ simulation training in the ED.
尽管急诊科已采用情景模拟来培训工作人员,以便更好地应对危急事件,但对于在这些模拟过程中,急诊科患者如何体验此类培训却知之甚少。因此,我们旨在探究急诊科患者对于工作人员应急培训的了解和看法,以及他们对模拟培训总体上的看法,尤其是对急诊科情景模拟培训的看法。
在这项定性研究中,我们采用了一种诠释性方法,包括对在急诊科等待治疗的患者进行视频诱导和半结构化访谈。同意参与的患者被问及他们对模拟的了解,然后观看一段心脏骤停模拟复苏的短视频。我们向参与者提出了关于他们对该视频的看法以及对急诊科模拟培训的开放式问题。访谈进行了录音、转录,并采用主题分析法进行分析。
我们采访了15名参与者。大多数人此前对模拟培训知之甚少或一无所知。观看视频在一些参与者中引发了情绪反应,在另一些参与者中引发了关于工作人员培训的务实反应,大多数参与者认为模拟培训是有用且必要的。参与者表示,为避免不必要的压力,他们希望在模拟发生时得到通知,以及在模拟过程中他们可能会看到和听到什么。大多数参与者预测,如果他们不需要紧急医疗护理,在进行模拟培训时,他们愿意多等大约30分钟去看医生。
以患者为中心的护理以及患者与医疗保健专业人员之间的护理伙伴关系是新西兰医疗保健和医学教育理念的基础。这需要各方之间进行有效的沟通,正如我们在急诊科情景模拟培训研究中所表明的那样。