Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA.
Pennsylvania College of Optometry, Salus University, Elkins Park, PA, USA.
Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2022 May 2;11(5):5. doi: 10.1167/tvst.11.5.5.
Data postprocessing with statistical techniques that are less sensitive to noise can be used to reduce variability in visual field (VF) series. We evaluated the detection of glaucoma progression with postprocessed VF data generated with the dynamic structure-function (DSF) model and MM-estimation robust regression (MRR).
The study included 118 glaucoma eyes with at least 15 visits selected from the Rotterdam dataset. The DSF and MRR models were each applied to observed mean deviation (MD) values from the first three visits (V1-3) to predict the MD at V4. MD at V5 was predicted with data from V1-4 and so on until the MD at V9 was predicted, creating two additional datasets: DSF-predicted and MRR-predicted. Simple linear regression was performed to assess progression at the ninth visit. Sensitivity was evaluated by adjusting for false-positive rates estimated from patients with stable glaucoma and by using longer follow-up series (12th and 15th visits) as a surrogate for progression.
For specificities of 80% to 100%, the DSF-predicted dataset had greater sensitivity than the observed and MRR-predicted dataset when positive rates were normalized with corresponding false-positive estimates. The DSF-predicted and observed datasets had similar sensitivity when the surrogate reference standard was applied.
Without compromising specificity, the use of DSF-predicted measurements to identify progression resulted in a better or similar sensitivity compared to using existing VF data.
The DSF model could be applied to postprocess existing visual field data, which could then be evaluated to identify patients at risk of progression.
使用对噪声不敏感的统计技术对数据进行后处理,可以减少视野(VF)系列的变异性。我们评估了使用动态结构功能(DSF)模型和 MM 估计稳健回归(MRR)生成的后处理 VF 数据检测青光眼进展的情况。
这项研究纳入了来自鹿特丹数据集的至少有 15 次就诊的 118 只青光眼眼。DSF 和 MRR 模型分别应用于前三次就诊(V1-3)的观察平均偏差(MD)值,以预测 V4 的 MD。V5 的 MD 用 V1-4 的数据预测,以此类推,直到预测到 V9 的 MD,创建了两个额外的数据集:DSF 预测和 MRR 预测。进行简单线性回归以评估第 9 次就诊的进展情况。通过调整来自稳定青光眼患者的假阳性率,并使用更长的随访系列(第 12 次和第 15 次就诊)作为进展的替代指标,评估了敏感性。
对于特异性为 80%至 100%,当用相应的假阳性估计值归一化阳性率时,DSF 预测数据集的敏感性大于观察数据集和 MRR 预测数据集。当应用替代参考标准时,DSF 预测数据集和观察数据集具有相似的敏感性。
在不影响特异性的情况下,使用 DSF 预测测量来识别进展可导致与使用现有 VF 数据相比更好或相似的敏感性。
马元煦