The Division of Environmental and Ecological Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA.
The Lyles School of Civil Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana, USA.
Integr Environ Assess Manag. 2023 Jan;19(1):272-283. doi: 10.1002/ieam.4631. Epub 2022 Aug 12.
The chemical footprint (ChF), which combines life cycle assessment (LCA) and quantitative risk assessment principles, shows promise for exploring localized toxicity impacts of manufacturing processes, which is not achievable with LCA alone. An updated ChF method was applied to the global annual production of a hard disk drive (HDD) rare-earth element (REE) magnet assembly, assuming a supply chain in East and Southeast Asia. Existing REE magnet assembly LCA inventories were combined with supplier manufacturing locations to create a cradle-to-gate spatial unit process inventory. Emissions from the electricity grid for each manufacturing site were downscaled to hydrobasins of interest using the Global Power Plant Database. The predicted no effect concentration (PNEC) was chosen as the ecotoxicity pollution boundary to determine the threshold for dilution of each chemical of concern (CoC) and to calculate the ChF. Finally, a high-resolution hydrological database provided volumes of the freshwater river reach draining each hydrobasin and was used to calculate the dilution capacity (DC), that is, the volume required to remain at or below the PNEC for each CoC. The total ChF of annual REE magnet assembly production was 6.91E12 m , with hotspots in watersheds in China and Thailand where REEs are processed and steel metalworking takes place. Metals were the primary CoCs, with cadmium and chromium(VI) comprising 77% of total ChF. Dilution factors ranged from 5E-09 to 9E + 03 of the DC of the waterbody, reflecting the spatial variability in both emissions and DC. An advanced ChF method was demonstrated for HDD REE magnets. Scoping is a key step required to reduce model complexity. The use of regionalized fate factors and standardized hydrological data sets improves the comparability of ChFs across hydrobasins. Additional work to combine data sets into readily available tools is needed to increase usability and standardization of the ChF method and promote wider adoption. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2023;19:272-283. © 2022 The Authors. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of Society of Environmental Toxicology & Chemistry (SETAC).
化学足迹(ChF)结合了生命周期评估(LCA)和定量风险评估原则,有望探索制造过程的局部毒性影响,而这是单独使用 LCA 无法实现的。应用一种经过更新的 ChF 方法,对全球每年生产的硬盘驱动器(HDD)稀土元素(REE)磁体组件进行了研究,假设供应链位于东亚和东南亚。将现有的 REE 磁体组件 LCA 清单与供应商制造地点相结合,创建了摇篮到大门的空间单元过程清单。利用全球电厂数据库,将每个制造地点的电网排放量细分为感兴趣的水文流域。选择预测无效应浓度(PNEC)作为生态毒性污染边界,以确定每种关注化学物质(CoC)的稀释阈值,并计算 ChF。最后,高分辨率水文数据库提供了每个水文流域排水的淡水河流流域的体积,并用于计算稀释能力(DC),即每种 CoC 保持在或低于 PNEC 所需的体积。年度 REE 磁体组件生产的总 ChF 为 6.91E12m,在中国和泰国的流域存在热点,这些流域进行 REE 加工和钢铁金属加工。金属是主要的 CoC,镉和六价铬(VI)占总 ChF 的 77%。稀释因子范围从水体 DC 的 5E-09 到 9E+03,反映了排放和 DC 的空间变异性。为 HDD REE 磁铁展示了一种先进的 ChF 方法。范围界定是减少模型复杂性的关键步骤。使用区域化命运因子和标准化水文数据集提高了 ChF 在不同水文流域之间的可比性。需要将数据集组合到现成的工具中,以提高 ChF 方法的可用性和标准化,并促进更广泛的采用。2023 年,综合环境评估与管理 19:272-283。©2022 作者。综合环境评估与管理由 Wiley 期刊公司代表环境毒理与化学学会(SETAC)出版。