Lindberg G, Thomsen C, Malchow-Møller A, Matzen P, Hilden J
Liver. 1987 Feb;7(1):43-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0676.1987.tb00314.x.
This paper shows that an algorithm for differential diagnosis of jaundice developed in Denmark has been successfully transferred for use in a Swedish hospital. The algorithm, which is based on data from nearly 1000 patients, utilises 21 items of information from the medical history, physical examination and blood chemistry. The algorithm recognises four diagnostic groups: benign obstructive jaundice, malignant obstructive jaundice, acute non-obstructive jaundice, and chronic non-obstructive jaundice. To each item of information, a score is attached reflecting its weight of evidence. Summing the scores for the symptoms and signs that are present leads to a probabilistic statement about the diagnosis. Because of missing data in the Swedish patient material, three of the items were excluded from the original algorithm. Corrections were made for differences in the distribution of diseases. In reclassification of 985 Danish patients the modified algorithm's "best bid", i.e. the diagnosis given the highest probability, was correct in 78% of cases. More important, 93% of the cases given a "confident" diagnosis (probability greater than 0.80) were correct. The corresponding figures when the algorithm was applied to Swedish patients were 76% and 93%, respectively. In both series the predicted probabilities were matched by a corresponding proportion of actual diagnostic hits. It is concluded that the algorithm leads to reliable estimates of diagnostic probabilities in jaundice and that the algorithm seems to work well in Sweden also.
本文表明,丹麦研发的一种黄疸鉴别诊断算法已成功移植到瑞典一家医院使用。该算法基于近1000名患者的数据,利用了病史、体格检查和血液化学检查中的21项信息。该算法识别出四个诊断组:良性梗阻性黄疸、恶性梗阻性黄疸、急性非梗阻性黄疸和慢性非梗阻性黄疸。对每一项信息都赋予一个分数,以反映其证据权重。将存在的症状和体征的分数相加,得出关于诊断的概率性陈述。由于瑞典患者资料中存在数据缺失,原始算法中的三项被排除。对疾病分布的差异进行了校正。在对985名丹麦患者进行重新分类时,修改后的算法的“最佳诊断”,即给出最高概率的诊断,在78%的病例中是正确的。更重要的是,93%被给予“确定性”诊断(概率大于0.80)的病例是正确的。当该算法应用于瑞典患者时,相应的数字分别为76%和93%。在这两个系列中,预测概率与相应比例的实际诊断相符。得出的结论是,该算法能对黄疸的诊断概率进行可靠估计,并且该算法在瑞典似乎也能很好地发挥作用。