Faculty of Medicine, Université de Montréal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, Maywood, Illinois, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2023 Feb;133(2):227-234. doi: 10.1002/lary.30174. Epub 2022 May 12.
OBJECTIVE: To map current literature on the educational use of extended reality (XR) in Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (OHNS) to inform teaching and research. STUDY DESIGN: Scoping Review. METHODS: A scoping review was conducted, identifying literature through MEDLINE, Ovid Embase, and Web of Science databases. Findings were reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for scoping review checklist. Studies were included if they involved OHNS trainees or medical students who used XR for an educational purpose in OHNS. XR was defined as: fully-immersive virtual reality (VR) using head-mounted displays (HMDs), non-immersive and semi-immersive VR, augmented reality (AR), or mixed reality (MR). Data on device use were extracted, and educational outcomes were analyzed according to Kirkpatrick's evaluation framework. RESULTS: Of the 1,434 unique abstracts identified, 40 articles were included. All articles reported on VR; none discussed AR or MR. Twenty-nine articles were categorized as semi-immersive, none used occlusive HMDs therefore, none met modern definitions of immersive VR. Most studies (29 of 40) targeted temporal bone surgery. Using the Kirkpatrick four-level evaluation model, all studies were limited to level-1 (learner reaction) or level-2 (knowledge or skill performance). CONCLUSIONS: Current educational applications of XR in OHNS are limited to VR, do not fully immerse participants and do not assess higher-level learning outcomes. The educational OHNS community would benefit from a shared definition for VR technology, assessment of skills transfer (level-3 and higher), and deliberate testing of AR, MR, and procedures beyond temporal bone surgery. Laryngoscope, 133:227-234, 2023.
目的:绘制耳鼻喉头颈外科学(OHNS)中扩展现实(XR)教育应用的现有文献图谱,为教学和研究提供信息。
研究设计:范围综述。
方法:通过 MEDLINE、Ovid Embase 和 Web of Science 数据库进行范围综述,通过扩展后的系统评价和荟萃分析的首选报告项目清单来报告发现。如果 OHNS 受训者或医学生使用 XR 进行 OHNS 教育目的,则将研究纳入。XR 被定义为:使用头戴式显示器(HMD)的完全沉浸式虚拟现实(VR)、非沉浸式和半沉浸式 VR、增强现实(AR)或混合现实(MR)。提取设备使用数据,并根据 Kirkpatrick 评估框架分析教育结果。
结果:在 1434 篇独特的摘要中,有 40 篇文章被纳入。所有文章均报告了 VR;没有讨论 AR 或 MR。29 篇文章被归类为半沉浸式,没有使用封闭式 HMD,因此,没有符合现代沉浸式 VR 的定义。大多数研究(40 篇中的 29 篇)针对颞骨手术。使用 Kirkpatrick 四级评估模型,所有研究均限于一级(学习者反应)或二级(知识或技能表现)。
结论:目前在 OHNS 中,XR 的教育应用仅限于 VR,无法完全使参与者沉浸其中,也无法评估更高层次的学习结果。VR 技术的共享定义、技能转移评估(三级及以上)以及对 AR、MR 和颞骨手术以外程序的精心测试,将使 OHNS 教育界受益。喉镜,133:227-234,2023。
JMIR Serious Games. 2021-7-8
Int Orthop. 2023-3
Biomed Eng Online. 2023-7-31
J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2023-2-22