Department of Sociology and Political Science, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway.
NTNU, Trondheim, Norway.
Scand J Public Health. 2022 Nov;50(7):1018-1023. doi: 10.1177/14034948221085394. Epub 2022 May 13.
While Marxist class analysis has strongly influenced the development of health inequality research, other aspects of Marx's theory have received less attention. Among the most relevant of Marx's theoretical contributions for social inequalities in health is the theory of alienation. As empirical applications of the theory of alienation are currently scarce, the purpose of this commentary is to invigorate interest in alienation theory within the field of health inequality research by demonstrating its potential to illuminate the relationship between social inequality, psycho-social affects and health outcomes.
Alienation theory describes how the class structure of capitalist societies creates experiences of powerlessness, estrangement and isolation. These experiences are further posited as emerging from the exploitation of labour, thus connecting social inequality to psychological wellbeing. Alienation theory is particularly compatible with psycho-social explanations of health inequalities, which similarly posits that social inequality affects health through psychological mechanisms. We argue that alienation theory contributes in three ways to health inequality research: a) by suggesting potential mechanisms and offering predictions that may be put to use in empirical research, b) by providing a potential explanation of the welfare state paradox, and c) by situating the psycho-social determinants of health within a critical analysis of the sources of social inequality in capitalist society.
.
虽然马克思主义阶级分析强烈影响了健康不平等研究的发展,但马克思理论的其他方面却较少受到关注。在与健康不平等相关的马克思理论贡献中,最重要的理论之一是异化理论。由于异化理论的实证应用目前还很少,因此本评论的目的是通过展示异化理论在健康不平等研究领域中的潜在应用,来激发人们对该理论的兴趣,阐明社会不平等、心理社会影响和健康结果之间的关系。
异化理论描述了资本主义社会的阶级结构如何产生无权感、异化和孤立感。这些体验被进一步假定是由劳动剥削产生的,从而将社会不平等与心理健康联系起来。异化理论与心理社会不平等的解释特别兼容,因为后者同样认为社会不平等通过心理机制影响健康。我们认为,异化理论在三个方面为健康不平等研究做出了贡献:a)通过提出可能的机制和预测,为实证研究提供了可能的依据;b)提供了对福利国家悖论的潜在解释;c)将健康的心理社会决定因素置于对资本主义社会社会不平等根源的批判性分析之中。