Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Division of Nutritional Sciences, University of Illinois Urbana Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801, USA.
Nutrients. 2022 Apr 30;14(9):1892. doi: 10.3390/nu14091892.
Beverages can provide improved nutrient intake and hydration, but also pose concerns related to overnutrition or contamination for children and adolescents who are in a time of critical growth. This narrative review aims to understand the impact of milk, 100% juice, and water consumption on health-related outcomes in youth. The literature review conducted used PubMed, Web of Science, and CABI global. Forty-five research articles met the quality criteria and were included. Health organization and governmental resources were also reviewed to identify current intake and consumption recommendations. All beverages in this review were associated with a variety of desirable and undesirable findings that spanned over 40 different health outcomes. Most studies that assessed milk lacked clear distinction between milk type (flavored vs. unflavored) or fat percentage, making it difficult to understand the impact of milk consumption. The relationship between milk intake and anthropometric-related outcomes were mixed within and across studies. Water was consistently associated with better hydration, while 100% juice and flavored milk intake was associated with more desirable dietary patterns or nutrients that children are currently not consuming adequate amounts of. The implications of these findings were discussed in the context of the National School Lunch Program (NSLP), while considering the impact of issues such as contaminated water and lactose intolerance. This review suggests that water may be an optimal default beverage option in the NSLP to promote hydration and accommodate beverage preferences for those with lactose intolerance.
饮料可以提供改善的营养摄入和水合作用,但对于处于关键生长时期的儿童和青少年来说,也存在与营养过剩或污染相关的问题。本叙述性评论旨在了解牛奶、100%果汁和水的消费对年轻人健康相关结果的影响。文献综述使用了 PubMed、Web of Science 和 CABI global 进行。符合质量标准并被纳入的研究有 45 篇。还审查了卫生组织和政府资源,以确定目前的摄入量和消费建议。本评论中的所有饮料都与各种理想和不理想的发现有关,这些发现跨越了 40 多种不同的健康结果。评估牛奶的大多数研究没有明确区分牛奶类型(调味与非调味)或脂肪百分比,因此难以理解牛奶消费的影响。牛奶摄入量与人体测量相关结果之间的关系在研究内和研究之间存在差异。水始终与更好的水合作用相关,而 100%果汁和调味牛奶的摄入与更理想的饮食模式或儿童目前摄入不足的营养物质相关。这些发现的意义在国家学校午餐计划(NSLP)的背景下进行了讨论,同时考虑了受污染的水和乳糖不耐受等问题的影响。本评论表明,水可能是 NSLP 中的最佳默认饮料选择,以促进水合作用,并适应那些乳糖不耐受的人的饮料偏好。