Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
Deparment of Health Metrics Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Risk Anal. 2022 Jul;42(7):1409-1422. doi: 10.1111/risa.13942. Epub 2022 May 14.
In 2019, the World Health Organization (WHO) named "Vaccine Hesitancy" one of the top 10 threats to global health. Shortly afterward, the COVID-19 pandemic emerged as the world's predominant health concern. COVID-19 vaccines of several types have been developed, tested, and partially deployed with remarkable speed; vaccines are now the primary control measure and hope for a return to normalcy. However, hesitancy concerning these vaccines, along with resistance to masking and other control measures, remains a substantial obstacle. The previous waves of vaccine hesitancy that led to the WHO threat designation, together with recent COVID-19 experience, provide a window for viewing new forms of social amplification of risk (SAR). Not surprisingly, vaccines provide fertile ground for questions, anxieties, concerns, and rumors. These appear in new globalized hyperconnected communications landscapes and in the context of complex human (social, economic, and political) systems that exhibit evolving concerns about vaccines and authorities. We look at drivers, impacts, and implications for vaccine initiatives in several recent historical examples and in the current efforts with COVID-19 vaccination. Findings and insights were drawn from the Vaccine Confidence Project's decade long monitoring of media and social media and its related research efforts. The trends in vaccine confidence and resistance have implications for updating the social amplification of risk framework (SARF); in turn, SARF has practical implications for guiding efforts to alleviate vaccine hesitancy and to mitigate harms from intentional and unintentional vaccine scares.
2019 年,世界卫生组织(WHO)将“疫苗犹豫”列为全球 10 大健康威胁之一。此后不久,COVID-19 大流行成为全球主要的健康关注点。几种类型的 COVID-19 疫苗已经以惊人的速度研发、测试和部分部署;疫苗现在是主要的控制措施,也是恢复正常的希望。然而,对这些疫苗的犹豫,以及对戴口罩和其他控制措施的抵制,仍然是一个重大障碍。导致世卫组织发出威胁的前几波疫苗犹豫,以及最近的 COVID-19 经验,为观察新形式的风险社会放大(SAR)提供了一个窗口。毫不奇怪,疫苗为问题、焦虑、担忧和谣言提供了肥沃的土壤。这些出现在新的全球化超连接通信环境中,以及在复杂的人类(社会、经济和政治)系统中,这些系统对疫苗和当局的关注不断演变。我们研究了最近几个历史案例中的疫苗计划的驱动因素、影响和意义,以及当前 COVID-19 疫苗接种的努力。研究结果和见解来自疫苗信心项目长达十年的对媒体和社交媒体的监测及其相关研究工作。疫苗信心和抵抗力的趋势对更新风险社会放大框架(SARF)有影响;反过来,SARF 对缓解疫苗犹豫和减轻有意和无意疫苗恐慌的危害有实际意义。