Department of Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Mercu Buana, Jakarta 11650, Indonesia.
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Kulliyyah of Engineering (KOE), International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM), Kuala Lumpur 53100, Malaysia.
Sensors (Basel). 2022 Apr 24;22(9):3267. doi: 10.3390/s22093267.
In Wireless Sensor Networks which are deployed in remote and isolated tropical areas; such as forest; jungle; and open dirt road environments; wireless communications usually suffer heavily because of the environmental effects on vegetation; terrain; low antenna height; and distance. Therefore; to solve this problem; the Wireless Sensor Network communication links must be designed for their best performance using the suitable electromagnetic wave behavior model in a given environment. This study introduces and analyzes the behavior of the LoRa pathloss propagation model for signals that propagate at near ground or that have low transmitter and receiver antenna heights from the ground (less than 30 cm antenna height). Using RMSE and MAE statistical analysis tools; we validate the developed model results. The developed Fuzzy ANFIS model achieves the lowest RMSE score of 0.88 at 433 MHz and the lowest MAE score of 1.61 at 433 MHz for both open dirt road environments. The Optimized FITU-R Near Ground model achieved the lowest RMSE score of 4.08 at 868 MHz for the forest environment and lowest MAE score of 14.84 at 868 MHz for the open dirt road environment. The Okumura-Hata model achieved the lowest RMSE score of 6.32 at 868 MHz and the lowest MAE score of 26.12 at 868 MHz for both forest environments. Finally; the ITU-R Maximum Attenuation Free Space model achieved the lowest RMSE score of 9.58 at 868 MHz for the forest environment and the lowest MAE score of 38.48 at 868 MHz for the jungle environment. These values indicate that the proposed Fuzzy ANFIS pathloss model has the best performance in near ground propagation for all environments compared to other benchmark models.
在部署于偏远和孤立的热带地区(如森林、丛林和开阔土路环境)的无线传感器网络中,由于环境对植被、地形、低天线高度和距离的影响,无线通信通常会受到严重影响。因此,为了解决这个问题,必须根据特定环境中最合适的电磁波行为模型来设计无线传感器网络通信链路,以获得最佳性能。
本研究介绍并分析了 LoRa 路径损耗传播模型在近地或发射器和接收器天线离地高度较低(天线高度小于 30 厘米)的信号传播中的行为。使用 RMSE 和 MAE 统计分析工具,验证了所开发模型的结果。所开发的模糊自适应神经模糊推理系统(Fuzzy ANFIS)模型在 433MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 0.88,MAE 得分最低为 1.61;在开放土路环境中,433MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 0.88,MAE 得分最低为 1.61。优化的 FITU-R 近地模型在森林环境中 868MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 4.08,MAE 得分最低为 14.84;在开放土路环境中,868MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 4.08,MAE 得分最低为 14.84。Okumura-Hata 模型在森林环境中 868MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 6.32,MAE 得分最低为 26.12;在森林环境中 868MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 6.32,MAE 得分最低为 26.12。最后,ITU-R 最大自由空间衰减模型在森林环境中 868MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 9.58,MAE 得分最低为 38.48;在丛林环境中 868MHz 时的 RMSE 得分最低为 9.58,MAE 得分最低为 38.48。这些值表明,与其他基准模型相比,所提出的模糊自适应神经模糊推理系统路径损耗模型在所有环境中的近地传播性能最佳。