Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Emerge, Inc. Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Acad Radiol. 2023 Jan;30(1):132-137. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2022.04.015. Epub 2022 May 20.
Learning to interpret thoracic images requires intensive instructor support. Given current cohort sizes at teaching hospitals in North America, instructor availability is rare. A Learning-by-concordance of perception (LbCP) online tool was introduced in a second-year course on lung and oxygenation. The LbCP tool presents thoracic images, students must point or outline abnormal structures directly on the screen and name the lesion. Thereafter, images with correct outline are superimposed on student's work and three key-messages are provided. We aimed to measure student perception of LbCP tool's usefulness and ease of use.
The online tool was developed and implemented for second year students for cohorts in 2016, 2017 and 2018 (n = 296; 303; and 280; N = 879). A survey, comprisingsix questions on a Likert scale was designed to measure perceptions about tool utility and ease of use. An ANOVA analysis was carried out to ensure the normality of the data, and a principal axis factor analysis was used to confirm the presence of the two expected clusters corresponding to our two dimensions.
The ANOVA conducted on the combined three year data set revealed an F value of 7.688 (p = 0.001), and principal axis factorial analysis revealed a one factor solution. The percentage of variance explained by the factor was 44.5%, with factor loadings leaning heavily in favor of the tool's perceived utility. A second factor was just shy of the eigenvalue threshold of 1.0 and could provide support for the tool's ease of use.
The online LbCP tool shows promising impact over three cohorts of students in three consecutive years. Students recognize the pedagogical value of the tool and express their willingness to use more of it in their training.
学习解读胸部影像需要密集的教师支持。鉴于北美教学医院目前的学员规模,教师资源稀缺。在第二年的肺部和氧合课程中引入了一种基于一致性学习的感知(LbCP)在线工具。该 LbCP 工具呈现胸部图像,学生必须直接在屏幕上指出或勾勒出异常结构,并命名病变。之后,将正确轮廓的图像叠加在学生的作业上,并提供三个关键信息。我们旨在衡量学生对 LbCP 工具的有用性和易用性的感知。
该在线工具是为 2016 年、2017 年和 2018 年的第二年学生开发和实施的(n=296;303;280;N=879)。设计了一个包含六个李克特量表问题的调查,以衡量对工具效用和易用性的看法。进行了方差分析以确保数据的正态性,并进行了主轴因子分析以确认存在与我们的两个维度相对应的两个预期聚类。
对三年综合数据集进行的方差分析显示 F 值为 7.688(p=0.001),主轴因子分析显示存在一个单因子解。该因子解释的方差百分比为 44.5%,因子负荷强烈倾向于工具的感知效用。第二个因子略低于 1.0 的特征值阈值,可以为工具的易用性提供支持。
该在线 LbCP 工具在连续三年的三批学生中显示出了有希望的影响。学生认识到该工具的教学价值,并表示愿意在培训中更多地使用它。