Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, MA.
University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA.
JCO Glob Oncol. 2022 May;8:e2100395. doi: 10.1200/GO.21.00395.
Geographic access to care is an important measure of health equity. In this study, we describe geographic access to cancer care centers (CCCs) in Rwanda with the current facilities providing care and examine how access could change with expanded care infrastructure.
Health facilities included are public hospitals administered by the Rwanda Ministry of Health. The WorldPop Project was used to estimate population distribution, and OpenStreetMap was used to determine travel routes. On the basis of geolocations of the facilities, AccessMod 5 was used to estimate the percentage of the population that live within 1 hour, 2 hours, and 4 hours of CCCs under the current (two facilities) and expanded care (seven facilities) scenarios. Variations in access by region, poverty, and level of urbanization were described.
Currently, 13%, 41%, and 85% of Rwandans can access CCCs within one, two, and 4 hours of travel, respectively. With expansion of CCCs to seven facilities, access increases to 37%, 84%, and 99%, respectively. There is a substantial variation in current geographic access by province, with 1-hour access in Kigali at 98%, whereas access in the Western Province is 0%; care expansion could increase 2-hour access in the Western Province from 1% to 71%. Variation in access is also seen across the level of urbanization, with current 1-hour access in urban versus rural areas of 45% and 8%, respectively. Expanded care results in improvement of 1-hour access to 67% and 33%, respectively. Similar trends were also noted across poverty levels.
Geographical access to CCCs varies substantially by province, level of urbanization, and poverty. These disparities can be alleviated by strategic care expansion to other tertiary care facilities across Rwanda.
地理可达性是衡量卫生公平性的一个重要指标。本研究描述了卢旺达癌症治疗中心(CCC)的地理可达性,包括当前提供服务的设施,并探讨了在扩大医疗基础设施后可达性将如何变化。
纳入的卫生机构包括由卢旺达卫生部管理的公立医院。利用世界人口项目(WorldPop Project)来估计人口分布,利用开放街道地图(OpenStreetMap)来确定出行路线。基于设施的地理位置,利用 AccessMod 5 来估算在当前(两家设施)和扩大(七家设施)服务情景下,居住在 CCC 1 小时、2 小时和 4 小时车程范围内的人口比例。描述了按区域、贫困和城市化程度划分的可达性差异。
目前,13%、41%和 85%的卢旺达人分别可以在 1 小时、2 小时和 4 小时内到达 CCC。随着 CCC 扩展到七家,可达性分别增加到 37%、84%和 99%。按省划分,当前的地理可达性存在很大差异,基加利的 1 小时可达性为 98%,而西部省的可达性为 0%;扩大服务范围可将西部省的 2 小时可达性从 1%提高到 71%。可达性也存在于城市化水平之间的差异,目前城市地区的 1 小时可达性为 45%,农村地区为 8%。扩大服务范围后,城市和农村地区的 1 小时可达性分别提高到 67%和 33%。在贫困水平方面也观察到类似的趋势。
CCC 的地理可达性在各省、城市化水平和贫困程度方面存在显著差异。通过在卢旺达其他三级保健设施中进行战略扩展服务,可以减轻这些差距。